MovieChat Forums > Black (2005) Discussion > Damn you Rani Mukherji !

Damn you Rani Mukherji !

posted 19 years ago by krax22
8 replies | jump to latest

She is bad actress.

[–] mikham 19 years ago

I think, going by the general consensus on these boards, you are in a very small minority who actually think so.

Would you like to offer some explanation or reasoning as to why you think she is a bad actress, rather than making a blanket statement like that?

[–] wetNdry 19 years ago

I think Black was Rani's movie. I don't see a damn critic praising her work in the movie, all of them are talking abt Aby or SLB.
I think she is the greatest in new generation, only she can compete with Kajol.
I loved her in Yuva. I think she reminded me of Smita Patil! It's not easy to do such role as she did in Yuva. Salute.

"My life is my message."..........GANDHI

[–] Catakiosk 19 years ago

I haven't seen that movie. What was her role? Didn't she win a Filmfare for that too?

[–] mikham 19 years ago

Yes, she won best supporting actress for Yuva at Filmfare.

[–] 19 years ago

[deleted]

[–] Catakiosk 19 years ago

How is the orignal poster an idiot for not liking Mukherji? I didn't like Black, but it doesn't make everybody else who did complete pinheads.

[–] Draconian_Drake 19 years ago

By far.....the best actress that we have today. She's way ahead of all her contemporaries in her acting skills. She's fantastic in Black. Also, brilliant in Yuva with Abhishek Bachchan !

[–] 19 years ago

[deleted]