MovieChat Forums > Astro Boy (2009) Discussion > Did anyone else feel uncomfortable that....

Did anyone else feel uncomfortable that...


..the real boy died?I thought that he would have somehow survived by the end of the movie...

THE WORLD IS YOURS

reply

[deleted]

That was pretty dark for a kids' film. I can't help but wonder what the little people thought about that.

Actually there were more than a few parts in this movie that made me think it's a little dark for a kid's movie. But maybe kids don't notice these things.

The world is a mess and I just... need to rule it.

reply

Well a lot of kids movie had dark elements to them if you think about many of the classic Disney movies had moments like the death of Simba's father in the Lion King or some of Don Bluth's movies like Secret Of Nimh that had scary moments. So having dark plot points in a kids' film is nothing new.

reply

Another part of the movie which I thought was pretty dark was in the Colliseum scene when Zog the big robot had seemingly intentionally stepped on and murdered that man. Sure, you find out a few seconds later that Astro Boy stops him from doing it, but for that few seconds it was a massive WTF moment for me.

reply

Not really that dark especially if you compared it to older Disney cartoons (before the leap to cg that is) before all this watered down kiddy movies we see nowadays.


OPEN YOUR EYES! dailymotion.com/video/xbi2hi_1993-chandler-molestation-extortion_news

reply

Nope...I guess you don't know much about Astroboy since that's what happens in the original story.

_______________________________________
Stupid people make me angry.

reply

In the original didn't he die in a car accident? I think that's not as bad as having the father watch something he created vaporize his son.

reply



'Nope...I guess you don't know much about Astroboy (Mighty Atom) since that's what happens in the original story'

True.

What you see is not necessarily what you get,
Not trying is dying, keep trying unto death....

reply

[deleted]

I thought that the robot absorbed Toby which is why I expected him to return at the end.

reply

I've never seen the original cartoon, so this was all new to me and I wasn't expecting that at all. I took my kids to see it (oldest turns 9 tomorrow, the youngest is 5) and they didn't really notice. I agree that a lot of kids movies do have some dark elements to it that we usually don't realize until we're older.



I'm wrong all the time, it's how I eventually get to right- GIL GRISSOM

reply

Yeah, it didn't seemed like Toby died; more like if he was absorbed or teleported; I was expecting he would return at the end or that he was inside the "peace" robot.

Weird thing is that Stone was just absorbed.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Not at all. The fact that he died makes this movie a lot more powerful. There is nothing worse than a movie without the courage to actually touch people trough tragedy. That's just a movie with no balls.. and IMO that's the number one hollywood-decease - the aversion towards anything remotely sad! It can very well mean that the audience just don't care at all. Children should watch something that actually touches them instead of the sad majority of mindless emotionally numb "it all turned out great in the end" stuff. Better that your kids came out of the theater crying than indifferent.

Actually.. I would have preferred that the ZOG robot died in the end.. sacrificing himself for Astro. But I guess you cant have it all :)

reply

[deleted]

He is more important..because he is the main character and killing him would put an end to possible sequels. But thats not the point.. the point is that it would have been a more powerful story if the sacrifice was real. Nobody sacrificed anything in this ending. But the fact that the original boy was killed still made this movie more powerful than most other childrens movies.

reply

In the original story Tobio was killed in a normal traffic accident, not by an evil robot. This boy's death is the essential origin of Astro, like Batman's parents, Spider-Man's uncle, or Superman's entire native planet.

reply

I think little kids thought it was the exact same person with super powers and not a robot replica I doubt try understood the kid really died

reply

As a kid I used to watch the Japanese version of Astro Boy and most Asian anime and cartoons are sad.. I don't remember the whole story but all I can remember is the feeling I had when I watched it. It has a sad atmosphere and it just has a shadow of sadness in it. It's like you always expect something sad going to happen. In this movie they put more depth for the cause of his death, it's like getting absorbed or like what another poster said "pulverized" by the robot. Also one would think was it the father's fault for not spending more time with Toby and instead made the robot who is actually going to kill his son or maybe if he let Toby stay with him to watch it then Toby would have been alive or maybe it is Toby's fault for not listening to his father. BUt then he is a kid, a very curious kid and a very smart kid at that. But they didn't dwell on his death too much though.

I think I will search the original (Japanese version) of this and see what happened after that, maybe it wasn't that sad after all..

One thing I didn't like much about the movie is the voice of the father, they shouldn't have gotten an actor who has a voice that is very recognizable. They used Charlize Theron and Kristen Bell's but their voice were just right Kristen's voice fits the character in my opinioin.

reply

I was pissed off, to be honest with you. I never once, throughout the entire movie, warmed up to AstroRobot. I couldn't believe they actually killed the REAL little boy and uplifted the fake machine. That sickened me.

Where have all the good writers gone?

reply

Since re-watching the 1980s Astroboy series, I wondered if a long story could have been drawn out from Osamu Tezuka's 'father's son dies and he tries to get him back through a robot' idea could have been its own story. Although since you were waiting for 90 minutes, it shows you were new to the series with no warning.

Although you sort of knew what you going to watch when you picked the movie, but I guess there's some other feelings and thoughts that you left the movie with, rather than watch-and-forget.

It is a tragic story, but if this setup hadn't been allowed when it was made when the manga was made in 1951, there would be no Astroboy stories or anything affiliated with it.

reply

I didn't, I was sad but I was like "Wow....disney got a pair with this" sad things happen. Bad things happen to good people, why does everyone have such a spazz fit when little kids learn that? Or the subject is even touched upon?

"Because I knew you, I have been changed...for good."
" You flip flopping ass piece of bitch"

reply

Not just that.

I thought it was pretty dark that Astro knowingly goes on a suicide mission to kill the red robot.

Just a really weird message for its intended audience: "Yes! Kill yourself! (If it's for the right reason, of course!)"

Of course, there was a [literal] deus ex machina that revives him, but Astro had no possible knowledge of this before he goes on his martyr mission.

reply