Amuro Ray vs. Kira Yamato


Who do you like more? Even though I've only seen him in Char's Counterattack, I'm going to have to go with Amuro Ray.

The further we go
And older we grow
The more we know
The less we show
~ The Cure

reply

I also have to go with Amuro Ray. I mean I like Kira (Except in Destiny) but Amuro is a better character. In Zeta he's portrayed as a empty man suffering from chronic battle fatigue due to the trauma of the one year war and in Char's Counter Attack as a dedicated soldier willing to risk his life to stop Char Aznable and his Neo Zeon army once and for all. His transformation from a spoiled whiny brat to a dedicated battle hardened soldier is amazing.

"Sic Vis Pacem, Parra Bellum"
(If you want peace, prepare for war)

reply

if you compare only the first series and seed kira yamato all the way.if you add in zeta and char's counter attack. amuro

reply

Amuro for now. But i hope Kira will get further development in a future movie or series (talking about that, will the CE movie announced so much time ago ever see the light?)

reply

Actually, I'm hoping that Shinn will get more development in a future movie or series. Fukuda and Morosawa really f-cked him (and the rest of us) over in Destiny.

I don't believe in Jesus
But I'm praying anyway
~ Dave Gahan

reply

I can see your point, but i really don't care about Shinn, i don't feel any real attachment to him, unlike SEED characters. The only SEED Destiny character that impressed me was Meer Campbell, she does develop very well during the series

reply

After what happened in Destiny, I don't particularly care for Kira or Lacus. Destiny should have been Shinn's show, not theirs.

I don't believe in Jesus
But I'm praying anyway
~ Dave Gahan

reply

It's true, it should have been Shinn's show, but in the end Shinn didn't do anything for me to care about him, while SEED characters remind me of the great time i had watching the first SEED show. Not even the bad things that Destiny did can ruin that for me

reply

It's true, it should have been Shinn's show, but in the end Shinn didn't do anything for me to care about him

I suppose Shinn would have done something for you in the end if Fukuda and Morosawa hadn't made him the bad guy.
while SEED characters remind me of the great time i had watching the first SEED show. Not even the bad things that Destiny did can ruin that for me

Well, I'm afraid all the bad things that Destiny did ruined Seed for me. Everytime I look at Lacus now, I just want to reach out and strangle her.

I don't believe in Jesus
But I'm praying anyway
~ Dave Gahan

reply

[deleted]

yep, i agree that it needed to catch up with him. But I would have liked it more if it happened somewhere in the middle of Destiny, so once he understood his mistakes the character could develop for the rest of the series instead of being one of the villains in the end

reply

[deleted]

they are working on a movie, not a series...

reply

[deleted]

Unless the movie does very well i doubt we'll see another C.E. animated series... I hope to see one though, C.E. needs another great series like the first SEED and the Astray mangas

reply

The Astray series should get animated, even if it's only a mini-series. I enjoyed them more than the main anime series. I saw the two five-minute MSV videos and they were pretty cool. The Astray characters were a lot cooler than Kira and company.

Lowe Guele - The real hero of the Cosmic Era.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lowe_Guele

reply

amuro > kira

kamille > shin

------
http://www.youtube.com/user/foottothenuts

reply