MovieChat Forums > Alone in the Dark (2005) Discussion > Petition: Stop Uwe Boll from making movi...

Petition: Stop Uwe Boll from making movies


From an interview with Uwe Boll:

Q: "Are you aware that there is a petition online, signed by 18,000 people, requesting that you stop making movies?"
Boll: "Yeah, I know that. 18,000 is not enough to convince me."
Q: "How many would it take?"
Boll: "One million. Now we have a new goal."
Q: "Hear that, haters? A challenge!"

The whole interview:
http://www.fearnet.com/MCNewsDetailPage.aspx?catid=30&mid=13788

VOTE HERE:
http://www.petitiononline.com/RRH53888/petition.html

reply

OMG hahaha thats awesome this guy is pathetic of saying 1 million becouse i doubt he will stop even if there are 10 million people signing the petition. Man i wish he just stops by himself its embarising didn`t he have internet his movies are rated low and on imdb he has atleast 2 or 3 movies in the bottom top 100 list.

reply

i just signed it...there's something like 200,000 now!! he should be ashamed...I'd go live in a cave, secluded from the rest of humanity if I were him...

So we got a corpse in a car, minus a head, in a garage, take me to it

reply

Lol, his movies can't get over 2.1 rating, maybe his goal is to fill the Bottom 100 movies on IMDB.

reply

Why do studios give this guy money to make movies? none of them make any profit...

I figured this guy would've dropped out of existence directing those type of films you see on Cinemax at 2am by now.

reply

And now he has the rights to Far Cry.

the end times are truly begun

reply

I've said it before: the people who vote on this poll should be ashamed. To crush anyone's dreams is wrong.

All you have to do, if you don't like Boll's movies, is not watch them.

But asking for him to stop making movies! That was amusing for about 0 seconds before it fell into cruel.

I guess I'm wasting my time. The people who think it's funny will never see reason.

reply

They are not making fun they take it serious. You can judge a Movie after you see it not before watching it and most People who love their Games even thou it is Boll they still want to see a Movie adaption but their Dreams are crushed aswell. Have you seen any singer without any voice and Talent for singing then BOOOOO him out so he stops singing and learns from it that he has no talent instead of liying to him and applauding that makes it worse. Here it implys the same this Guy has no Talent at all or atleast he chooses the wrong Movies to make. Having 2-3 or even more Movies in top bottom of IMDB is more than Proof enough that Most People don`t like his Movies at all. But as sia d he will never stop even with 10 Million to sign this petition he will then say it was a joke or something.

reply

To see someone completely ruin game after beloved game is enough to ask them to stop.
Maybe it's cruel.
But cruelty is needed in some cases.

reply

People arent being cruel in demanding that he stops making movies.
People who say that they should just stop seeing his movies if they dont like them are forgetting the main important reason people are angry at this guy.

Hes buying the rights to these films, meaning that the fans of the games out there will never get to see a good honest try at making a movie based on some of their favourite games.

Thus killing the "dream" .

reply

I am so glad blizzard turned him down.

The world of Uwe will actually kill lich king himself...

reply

Uwe Boll has a production company (Boll KG), he produces his own movies. He isn't backed by movie studios.

In the DVD commentary of Alone in the Dark, Boll explains how he funds his films:

"Maybe you know it but it's not so easy to finance movies in total. And the reason I am able to do these kind of movies is I have a tax shelter fund in Germany, and if you invest in a movie in Germany you get basically fifty percent back from the Government."

=/

reply

He finances all of his own movies. No one in their right mind would support his movies.

reply

This whole petition is bunk. Has anyone ever heard of freedom of speech? The man has every right to keep making movies, and a bunch of armchair-activists signing a stupid online petition won't change that.

reply

which is a shame cus his films are bollox, and a "stupid" petition with 200,000 signitures is pretty impressive. *beep* freedom of speech the guys a cnut.

your opinion is the wrong one.

reply

[deleted]

How does he "ruin" great games? These are movies; you don't get to play them.

If you don't like his work, you aren't going to like anything else he does either, so why see his films? It's like seeing every Hitchcock film ever made and complaining that he doesn't use short jewish girls as his leading ladies. You KNOW what he is going to do and it is not to your taste. Be a grown-up and just don't bother with them.

This petition is stupid--life isn't "Survivor"; you don't get to vote people out, especially if they control their own means of production.

reply

Yeah, its a shame we dont live in a censorship dictatorship where few loud speaking people can dictate what other people can and cannot say/write/film. the current model of "good products get sold, bad dont" certainly doesnt work, we must use some dictator (but of course only one i agree with) to tell us what we can and cannot say.
And IMDB is guilty of this, it has censored a word in your post. so enjoy your slavery.

---------------------------------------------
Applied Science? All science is applied. Eventually.

reply

Yes, but he doesn't have the moral right to ruin good game franchises.

reply

How does making a bad movie out of a good game "ruin" it? Let's take Street Fighter, for example. The movie sucked big floppy donkey-d.ck, but the game still rules. Stop crying about nothing.

reply

I didn't say it ruins the game, but the franchise. But maybe I didn't put it clear enough - making a bad movie out of a good game ruins the possibility for the franchise to unfold its potential in other areas (in this case cinema). Lots of the movies Uwe made could have been great, if someone else had acquired the rights for them. And since those movies were once produced, it's highly unlikely that another adaptation would be made in the future. So now, thanks to Uwe, there's no chance that we'll ever see a good movie based on Alone in the Dark, for example. Perhaps there are people who have always dreamed of such a movie and to them that's hardly 'nothing'.

reply

I agree with m-vaskes. As a kid, I ALWAYS dreamed of a movie-adaption of Alone in The Dark. I was pumped when I heard it was coming... and when I heard Uwe ToiletBoll was directing/producing it, I became really... well, I really don't have a word for it, but I remember telling myself over and over again "Come on, Alone in The Dark! No-one can skr3w it up THAT BAD." And when I saw it, I felt all my childhood dreams of the movie get supprise intercourced and crushed. So yeah, he is terrible. I wish he'd quit being such a douche and just stop directing.

reply

IMDB-10592! God bless you sir, i only knew the bare minumum of the petition but alerted the other msg boards of his movies about it! Go reply the petition site on my thread on each of his movies! We need to ge that MILLION!

reply

Status update: 319,878 Signatures Total

http://www.petitiononline.com/mod_perl/signed.cgi?RRH53888

__________
Last movie watched: The Tenant (7/10)

reply

As soon as I heard there was a petition I signed as well. Seriously, how the hell does this guy continue to get funding for his crappy movies?

I'm a mushroom cloud layin' mother&$#@er, mother@#$@er!

reply

stupid topic. Anyone can make a movie. And anybody else can decide to watch it or not.

reply

354,343 Signatures!

may the farce be wif u

reply

[deleted]

Okay, so I was curious to see what progress had been made since the last post here of about 360k, and found that the whole petitiononline.com site shut down in 2014, redirecting people to change.org, so the old petition is lost, and searching change.org finds no matching petition (probably for reasons I'll get into below).

As to the whole 'illegality' of this petition ("It infringes on Boll's freedom of speech" "well you're infringing on MY freedom of speech by making/signing this petition" "nuh-uh" "uh-huh"...ad nauseam): he's allowed to do what he wants, and you're allowed to say what you want about that...with the understanding that he's NOT beholden to LISTEN to you, public statements notwithstanding. If you HAD got the one million names, that's cool, but there's nothing saying that his remark wasn't just an offhand joke that he had no intention of following though with.



BUUUUUT, guess what? Looks like all you haters get your wish (but not for reasons you'd hope):

http://www.bbc.co.uk/newsbeat/article/37787337/uwe-boll-director-of-the-worst-film-ever-says-hes-retiring


Essentially, his target market of Direct-to-DVD movies is drying up with the rise of Netflix, Hulu, and other digital distribution providers, so he's going to stop.

This kind of puts the whole 'I do this because I love cinema' claim of his to be specious; clearly he's showing that he's been doing this to make money.

Also a skeptic might ask "why doesn't he just redirect his efforts for 'Direct-to-Netflix' films (I've seen tons on there that could NOT have EVER had a theatrical release), and then would wonder if he's simply getting older and tiring of doing the same thing for so long...and might wonder if all the wonderful tax incentives and write-offs that the German government were giving his productions have been shut down in these years of economic frugality...but down that way lies tinfoil hats...

So to all those who were genuinely putting hope in an online petition actually DOING SOMETHING to change the actions of a single private entrepreneur, maybe the fact that after FIVE YEARS there was only a little over a THIRD of the signatures required says something about the effectiveness of 'wishing on a star'...

...while all those people who posted here saying "Naw, boy - vote with your MONEY; if you don't want him to make any more crap films, stop paying to see them" turned out to be quite accurate in hindsight, didn't they? Props to all of you, and I'm wondering if any of you have any ideas for lottery numbers... ;)

Those who dance are considered insane by those who can't hear the music." - George Carlin

reply