Plothole


Wouldn't an airplane have passed overhead in any of the time they lived there? Or really any kind of modern-day happening? Then what? Just tell them it's a monster?

reply

Go down a few posts in this thread:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0368447/board/thread/241128750

Hmm. There was another thread with more on the subject, that I guess has been deleted. Main points I remember:
- An airplane at altitude doesn't look like anything from the ground, at least if you (a) are unaware of airplanes and (b) have seen contrails and little glittery things in the sky your whole life. Nobody freaked out about clouds before anyone understood what they are.
- Their woods were sufficiently isolated and - in particular - remote from airports, that there were no low-altitude planes visible.
- Maybe there was some kind of air traffic restriction. That's possible, though not enormously likely, in reality, but apparently doable in the fictional world of the movie. I don't make that a plothole so much as a modest stretch of believability.

reply

i remember something my daughter remarked during the complete banning of air traffic in 2001, how quiet and clear of contrails was the sky, even if you can't see the plane the contrail is visible.


"Does it make a movie "good" because you "like" it? No, it doesn't..." - Roger Ebert

reply

This was explaimed in the movie when modern day kid was stealing the medicine. His boss mentioned how Walker paid off a lot of money to the government to keep the preserve a no fly zone. So planes werent even allowed to fly over that area; which would explain why they wouldnt see any

reply

This was explaimed in the movie when modern day kid was stealing the medicine. His boss mentioned how Walker paid off a lot of money to the government to keep the preserve a no fly zone. So planes werent even allowed to fly over that area; which would explain why they wouldnt see any


Exactly. Maybe watch a movie next time, before you have questions about it.

reply

The poster obviously did watch the movie. It's not hard to miss a single line of dialogue out of a two-hour film.

-There is no such word as "alot."

reply

Actually it wouldn't necessarily matter if airplanes flew over because the children who were born there would not know to think anything strange about the existence of airplanes. The elders could have just made up some story about them and the kids would simply believe them as they have everything else they were told. It's only importance to mention that they don't fly over is for the viewer because many of us would nitpick about much in the manner as we are doing here.


He's taking the knife out of the Cheese!
Do you think he wants some cheese?


reply

Read somewhere it was a no fly zone

reply



- Just tell them it's a monster? -

Isn't it exactly what religions have been doing for thousands of years?

reply

[deleted]

I never bought the movie's explanation and always thought it was just a writer's convenient trick. Who exactly do you "pay off" to prevent planes from flying over? The FAA? Congress? The EPA? this would only draw attention and suspicion to the place. Saying it would disturb the wildlife in the preserve wouldn't work because all kinds of nature preserves have planes flying overhead with no bad effects. So I accept it as a plot convenience that at least shows the writer thought of the problem, but I don't think it could have actually been done.

reply

^^ THIS!!! EXACTLY THIS!!!!

I think you're the opposite of paranoid, I think you walk around with the delusion people like you.

reply

obsessing over a minor detail.

reply

[deleted]