MovieChat Forums > Sorstalanság (2005) Discussion > Expensive propaganada fantasy film farra...

Expensive propaganada fantasy film farrago


The alleged 'writer' of this crazy farrago, Mister Imre Kertesz recently denied that he is a Hungarian or has anything to do with Hungary. In fact, he is a German citizen living in Berlin, capital of Germany, for many years.

This fact, and many others, make this work entirely a work of fiction, and not a very good one at that.

Also, not helping matters is Mister Kertesz's comments on the DVD interview, in which he calls Steven Spieleberg a clueless jerk for making "Schindler's List," and calls Mr. Spielberg's Shoal Foundation a useless enterprise as well.

Finally, the camerman who allegedly 'directed' this mess has never directed any film before this one... or since then. Just because someone can put a roll of film inside a film camera does not mean that one can direct a movie.

The whole footage looked like it was shot on expired raw stock, anyhow. It is neither in color nor in Black & White, but somewhere in-between. Maybe the director had some left-over unexposed film rolls from his previous cameraman jobs, and decided to make a movie with it?

reply

I'm not sure what the point of your argument is. You jump from claim to claim, but being unsure of your reasoning, it makes me question your motives and credibility.

reply

You do know Kertesz was a Holocaust suvivor and rejected his Hungarian nationality because of how badly he was treated during the Nazi and communist eras, right?

reply