Dark's spells


Why in all the world are they German??? I mean, they're cool and all, if you understand german, but why not use a language anyone can understand?
*giggle* And his pronounciation is not the best.... but that's off the topic.
Well... Anyone out there know?

------
don't pay attention to me.

reply

First, they're not in German... they're in Latin.

Most spells are.

reply

they are german. I understood them. If they were latin, I firstly would NOT have understood them, and secondly I would've run away screaming. ;)
I quote, from episode 3:
"Ich möchte helfen"
And episode 7:
"Ich trage Dunkelheit (...) und es schläft ewig"
I know my mother language when I hear it, and even though a lot of that spell is pretty much incomprehensible, it's still definatly german.

------
don't pay attention to me.

reply

OK, I'm conviced.

reply

so... any idea WHY it's german? *really really wants to know*

------
don't pay attention to me.

reply

Unknown.

reply

*sigh* too bad. :(

------
don't pay attention to me.

reply

Bumping old threads, wheew! Anyway, why not let Dark chant his sealing incantations in German? It obviously should be a language other than Japanese (well duh) or English/Engrish (which is clearly reserved for Hio-chan, and aren't we ever thankful for that?). So German [or at least the part that was definitely German- despite it being my native tongue, I didn't catch much more than the few lines you already quoted] seems like a reasonable enough choice to me, considering that Japanese in general have a weakness of some sorts for that language. This is particularly true in Anime (Weiss Kreuz is probably one of the most famous examples), and D.N.Angel apparently is no exception- hey, they actually named a character "Ehrlich", remember? ^^


"We spread the time as we can, but in the end the world takes it all back." [Roland Deschain]

reply

yeah, but WHY do anime have a weakness for spells in german?!? I just don't get it!!! It sound hard and ugly and... although I can understand why they don't want to be cliché and use Latin, they could use something else... greek or persian or, I dunno. At the very least they should pay attention that the german is correct, not to mention comprehensible. I mean "Weiss Kreuz"?!? talk about bad grammar skills.
The Qincy and the Bount in BLEACH use german spells too, I've noticed. At leat the grammar there is correct.

------
don't pay attention to me.

reply

Well, many Japanese (and as such, many potential Anime recipients, who are the calculation basis for Anime producers) are germanophile to some degree. This may be an aftereffect of the alliance during WW II and/or caused by the generally good international relations between Germany and Japan. It does work vice versa too, after all: Many people in the German-speaking part of Middle Europe have an affinity of some sorts for Japanese food, language, culture etc. (and yes, the still ongoing Anime Hype starting in the late 90s certainly has something to do with this as well.)
So, it does seem reasonable enough to see German words and expressions (however inadequately used) popping up in Anime every once in a while. The grammar is usually questionable at best due to the fact that Japanese and German are vastly different languages, I presume (which probably is also one of the key problems defining the phenomenon known as "Engrish"). Japanese is an agglutinative language while German is mostly synthetic, word order and sentence structure are different, Japanese uses a syllabic script while German uses an alphabetic script, etc.
Alas, German is quite hard to learn for someone who doesn't have it as their native language (or so I've heard), and being Japanese- thus coming from an entirely different cultural and linguistic background- certainly won't exactly help, either. So, mistakes are understandable (and plentiful) on such occasions.
While Ancient Greek might be a nice-sounding alternative for incantations and all that jazz, I suppose Japanese would have an even harder time getting a grasp of it than they already have with the German language. Not to mention that Ancient Greek is passed down mostly by using Greek letters (duh), which would be an additional challenge for our poor Anime producers- with German, they at least already know the letters, since Japanese certainly use Romaji often enough.

"We spread the time as we can, but in the end the world takes it all back." [Roland Deschain]

reply

*giggle* thanks. ^^ I didn't quite expect such a long detailed reply, but, I got it! thanks!
still... why choose a language as ugly as german?!? I bet japanese have lots of other countries with good international relations! (yeah I hate my mother language =P ) augh whatever I think my mind's just ignoring any logical reasons. *sigh* don't pay attention to me.

------
don't pay attention to me.

reply

Maybe they were hoping Tiffany Grant would play Dark, but at the last minute they got Vic Mignona instead.

::rimshot::

I sleep in Louisiana, but my head is in the clouds...(OW! Stupid airplane...)

reply

Because German is a sexy language :P

reply