that moffat guy


he was part of a band..how can he be a part of canadian idol? He's not even that good!!

reply

Yah, I don't get that either. I think he has already had a chance. Let other people who wouldn't likely get that chance have it. Plus, with his contacts, can't he get a contract on his own? I don't even know why the judges put him through.

reply

I was wondering that too..

He's already had big hits with his brothers "The Moffats" isn't it supposed to be amateur singers?

I think he should thank the judges that he got this far and bow out of the competition.

Dave let someone that might not have the opportunity you've already had get a chance.

reply

The rules are that you can't have a current recording contract or talent representation, which he obviously doesn't have because he qualified to be on the show. BTW, he was good, it's just too bad that there are a lot of Canadians voting who don't know good singing when they hear it.

reply

GO CANADA!!!!!

reply

Hey. This year we get the guy from McMasters and James. lol i'm just waiting for one of the guys from Hanson to show up on american idol.

'Whenever I have to do something quickly, I always bring a turtle'
- The Swan Princess

reply

...google 'dave moffatt' you know why the moffatts broke up dont you?

-and don't be mean about hanson, they're busy adults with wives and babies and still have a strong fan base

reply

why did they break up? cuz he was gay? haha when i listen to them now i realized how not so good they were and i was like a HUGE fan well not huge but you know
i know clint and bob have their band - which i dont mind and scott has his which i've never heard but his voice was always too high
i really liked Bang Bang Boom and Dave's voice in it.
of all of them to come out of the closet i expected Scott *shrugs*
im not trying to sound mean

reply

[deleted]

ya not all the idols are good. i cant stand melissa o'neil and i'm not a fan of rob james either.

reply

[deleted]