MovieChat Forums > Canadian Idol (2003) Discussion > why the low rating?

why the low rating?

posted 17 years ago by stickman-0
7 replies | jump to latest

if you like american idol you should like canadian idol! whats the differance?

[–] Realist87 17 years ago

Canadian Idol is the whitest show on Earth. No diversity at all, and that's the truth. *yawns*

what? i don;t think that's the reason. I think the judges suck, like they're all annoying(ya i can't spell)but i watch it anyway...

If people make fun of you, you must be doing something right-amy lee

[–] desiree_chick 16 years ago

That is EXACTLY why I cannot watch the show. Did you at least notice the latest top 24? I mean, the one of only TWO people of COLOUR--not just black, I mean all races--already have been voted out. (I just caught the tail end of eliminatins while changing the channel.)

And it is always the mediocure(sp)rock types that win that would never stand a chance to, say, David Cook or Chris Daughtry. We pride ourselves in multiculturalism, so shouldn't that reflect that on a very popular Candaian program that has all walks of life coming together?

[–] napkinbob-1 17 years ago

Becasue the show is a joke. No one can sing, and even when they are horrible, the judges love it. No one has any stage prescence and everything about it feels cheap.

Are you watching closely?

[–] Eggie_Stulrex 17 years ago

I think the big reason is that nobody knows the judges. Like that should matter. They're way better than Randy, Paula, and Simon.

It wouldn't be unwise to compare anime to Japanese RPGs.

[–] ellino_kanadezo 16 years ago

Both are good, but in reality American Idol has alot better singers and well also more entertaining. Anybody who makes Top 24 on American Idol (MAYBE even top 40) should easily win the title on Canadian Idol.

Copyright © 2008

[–] AllStar63 16 years ago

Canadian Idol is more entertaining to me I think you guys should youtube Liam Styles Chang or Montana Martin Iles performances, you would never see that anywhere else trust me.

EMOLICIOUS