2nd worst book of the series


2nd only to The Last Battle. And yet it gets the biggest accolades.

I didn't make it past the first movie even though Prince Caspian and Dawn Treader are my favorite books of the run. The film just didn't grab me. Made me fear what they'd do to the next ones.

reply

Prince Caspian (movie) sucked. I like Dawn Treader even though they definitely made changes for the adaptation. It was my favorite so far. So I'm bummed Silver Chair isn't happening now.

reply

They mucked up all the movies. None really captured the spirit of the books.

I never thought about it, but you might be right about it being the second least best of the series.

reply

I thought it was the best of the three movies so you probably wouldnt have liked the others. (I thought they were ok, like a 6.5)

Im reading The Magician's Nephew now and then will read The Last Battle. I like them all but I would really like to see A Horse and His Boy as a movie.

reply

Agreed. AHaHB would work well since it is stand alone and a more encapsulated tale.

reply