Opinions


I've seen a lot of criticisms about this movie concerning the acting and the fact that there may or may not be stereotypes, cultural inaccuracies and cliches. Does anyone know anything about this, and if so what do you have to say. I'm really looking forward to this film and I find it hard to believe that the movie sucks that bad. I think that Eddie Spears is a good actor who has a lot of potential and I'm a little surprised at some of the bad things that have been said about his acting. I'm not saying he's the greatest, but I don't think he sucks either.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

In my opinion, we need more movies like Black Cloud. It does Native Americans like myself to see contemporary depictions of Natives, as opposed to the usual historical depictions. I wonder if other countries assume that we Natives still live in tee-pees and hunt buffalo.

I am Navajo, I know people that were extras in Black Cloud, in fact, I was in Window Rock, AZ when Mr. Schoder was seeking permission to film Black Cloud. He went to the council chambers and everything.

Mr. Schoder was very respectfull to our tribe. Its nice to see our people on the big screen. Unlike more "glamourous" tribes, we don't live in tee-pees or wear buckskin and its nice to see that film makers didn't play into that stereotype.

reply

I have the DVD of this film; it was never shown in theatres where I live (Texas), so I bought it. I thought it was a very respectable debut for Rick Schroder as a filmmaker. Russell Means was a standout as the boxing coach. Eddie Spears did a good job as the angry young man going through an identity crisis when he suddenly discovers that he is mixed blood. I'd never seen Julia Jones in a film before; she is beautiful and does a good job as the single Mom who's in love with Black Cloud.
One of the best things about this movie is the film location. The cinematography of the Navajo Nation lands, especially Canyon de Chelly, is spectacular. At times, I felt like I was watching one of the old John Ford westerns. I especially liked the scenes with the wild horses running free. Another nice touch was the music by Tim McGraw. He makes his acting debut in this film (it was shot before Friday Night Lights). Although it was his first try at acting, he seemed very natural in the role of the sheriff.
I reviewed the film for Amazon (where I bought it), and gave it four out of five stars. As far as bad reviews, don't let that stop you from seeing the film. Often, I really like films that are panned by the film critics. They have their own agenda you know, and promoting Native American films is probably not a part of that agenda. In case you mistake my remarks, I am not a Native American; I have no ax to grind here. I'm just telling it like I see it.

reply

I am Navajo and didn't like this film very much (I have no idea why). But I am greatful that it didn't show that we still live in Teepees (The Plains Indians live in teepees, we live in hogans) or wear buckskin clothing.
I have never come across a person who asked me stupid stereotypical questions like if I live in a teepee, or...if I made it rain last night. But I DO know some people who experience those questions. The weirdest question so far was "Are you a Navajo?" which was asked by another Navajo.

reply

I thought Eddie Spears did great in this movie! I rather enjoyed it. Loved the story and all that beautiful Navajo imagery -- Didn't love the script or some of the overly cheesy scenes.

"Shocks are so much better absorbed with the knees bent." - Lord Summerisle

reply