Let's discuss the film.


None of the few threads on this board contain any intelligent discussion of this film. This thread is for that exactly.

There are a lot of interesting ideas presented in this film and they deserve to be discussed.

One thing I noticed during the purgatory section is that it seemed that Godard was almost repenting for his outspoken Maoism. Quotes such as "Killing a man to defend an idea is just killing a man," or something like that.

Ideas?



Do you know who I am? I am a huge fan of radio control!

reply

[deleted]

Thanks for the comments. Could you expand your first comment a little please? I know some of Godard's sixties work and love it, but not only have I not seen much of it (yet) but I don't know much about the situation then.

I hope some more people come to this thread, because I agree that this film is great.



Do you know who I am? I am a huge fan of radio control!

reply

[deleted]

There are countless books written about the 60s/68s/post world war II situation - you will easily find
them as well as books about cinema and/or Godard of that time.

I don't think many people will join this thread - not just because of this unpopular film but the whole
subject - which is, imo, almost impossible to discuss on the internet.


See, this is why I wasn't impressed with this film. Godard obviously knows very little about the historical subjects he presents in this film, and his "characters" (though each of them are forgettable) have conversations about these subjects that leave you with the impression that they got all that info from their partisan college professors. That seems largely like Godard's post-1960's output in a nutshell.

I know, I know: I'm one of those pathetic cinephiles who whines about how Godard just isn't what he used to be. But... I do! Bergman made Saraband in his 80's and Sidney Lumet made Before The Devil Knows You're Dead in his 80's'. Both of those films are masterpieces. Sure, Godard would probably dismiss those films as "conventional", but hey--at least they're films.

Godard just wasted all of the last decade doing... what? If I've missed any important titles, I apologize. I really do. I've been searching in vain for any late titles from his career that can help redeem him in my eyes. But superfluous films like Notre Musqiqe don't exactly make me excited to keep wanting to wade through all of it.

"What I don't understand is how we're going to stay alive this winter."

reply

Just saw Notre musique for the second time. It just keeps getting better. The best film of the decade, without a doubt. But yes I agree that the film is almost impossible to talk on the internet. Luckily I was able of talking about it in real life.

reply