This show could be successful on HBO
Unlike Comedy Central, HBO would properly fund and promote the show. The comics would have the freedom to say whatever they want without having to look over their shoulder.
Tough Crowd was the funniest and edgiest show to ever air on a basic cable network. The people who say it sucked either A) don't understand smart comedy, B) only watched 1 episode and concluded their opinion of the show, C) Have a personal hate for Colin(go see him live, he's great), or D) were offended by Nick DiPaolo and flooded Comedy Central with complaints.
I don't really understand all the hate coming from this board either. It seems like a lot of people are happy the show got canceled, if you didn't like the show why the hell would you come post on the message board for it? I think it's just one of those things where you're blinded by hate. You hate one individual therefor you cannot be open to anything surrounding that person.
HBO needs to pick up Tough Crowd because it's better fit for their viewer demographic. Overall the average person tuning into comedy central doesn't have the attention span to wait for a punch line, instead they need simple comedy that requires you not to think like Drawn Together, Blue Collar comedy, and all the other garbage shows on Comedy Central.