MovieChat Forums > Elektra (2005) Discussion > WORST comic book movies EVER

WORST comic book movies EVER


here my list of dreadful comic book movies
1.electra
2.catwomen
3.superman returns
4.the phantom
5.fantastic four
6.the hulk (ang lee version)
7.daredevil
8.spiderman 3 (not that the others were great)
9.the punisher
10.x men origins wolvirine

also as a side note the entire batman franchise from the 90s

reply

[deleted]

Funny. ASM is among my TOP 5.

"He drank. He fought. He made his ancestors proud!"

reply

I guess you've never seen Superman III, Superman IV, Supergirl, Batman Forever or Batman & Robin, because some of those you mentioned were better than the five I just mentioned. :)

In fact, I even enjoyed some of those in your list.

Takin' out the trash, trailer park style!!

reply

I would agree with:
Daredevil
The Phantom
Catwoman
But ... I kinda liked Elektra and i really think "Wolverine" gets a bad rap! Hulk woulda been better with someone other than Bana ... he was badly mis-cast! I can take or leave the Supermans, and ... I STILL like Keaton's "Batman's"! F-4's ... so-so.

reply

When I was in high shool my art teacher asked me to draw something, but I got lazy and drew anything just to get a grade. Its the same with hollywood, they get bored with the material, and have no respect for the art of comic book characters. Example elektra's costume in this movie is unrealistic for a ninja to sneak around unnoticed in leather high heeled boots. The comic book elektra has a more stealthy ninja dress and shoes.

reply

[deleted]

Punisher: war zone and the spirit are also lacking.

reply

[deleted]

The Crow. Very disappointing and tame. Tragic that Lee died, but also tragic that he died in a tepid watered down version of a superior comic.

reply

Electra was ok
catwomen was terrible
superman returns was terrible
I liked the phantom
fantastic four which one? The 94 or 05? I thought the 05 version was ok
the hulk (ang lee version) was ok
daredevil was a good movie
spiderman 3 was ok
the punisher was good movie,War Zone was terrible
I love x men origins wolvirine

also as a side note the entire batman franchise from the 90s

The only batman movie I disliked was Batman and Robin




reply