Bernard Cornwall


I would like see an adaptation of Bernard Cornwell's sequence of King Arthur books. Those of you who have read the books agree?

reply

I would absolutely love that and have been saying this for years! To me no Arthurian material out there would make a better adaptation. But I don't know whether it is reasonable to hope for that or not. Now that Cornwell's Lost Kingdom is being adapted, I don't know whether to take this as a good sign that Cornwell's Arthurian trilogy might be adapted next, or if it's a sure sign that it won't be, because producers would think it too similar to The Lost Kingdom...

"Occasionally I'm callous and strange."

reply

I would love to see Cornwells novels on screen. No author does the research he does

reply

Yes and no. He's a very fine storyteller, but this series frustrated the heck out of me when he went through the preceding generation(s) before Arthur - and then when he finally arrived at Arthur's generation, he ignored Arthur in favor of focusing on other characters! That annoyed me because I had read the previous installments precisely as a buildup to Arthur himself.

So, sure, use Cornwell's material - but make it eventually focus on Arthur himself!

reply

I think you're confusing Cornwell's Warlord Chronicles with some other material. Cornwell doesn't look into the lives of the preceding generations. In fact when the narrator, Derfel, first sees Arthur, towards the beginning of the novel, Arthur is already a grown man and a famous warrior.
You may be thinking of Stephen Lawhead's Pendragon Cycle? The original trilogy titles go Taliesin, Merlin, Arthur; he then added Pendragon and Grail. Victor Canning does something similar, although in a single book, in The Crimson Chalice, so it could be that one, too. But it is more common to mix up Cornwell and Lawhead.

"Occasionally I'm callous and strange."

reply

You're completely right; thanks for correcting me. I was thinking of Jack Whyte's Arthurian saga. But with Cornwell's I have another problem: I haven't read that series, but from what I've heard he portrays Arthur as antichristian, which goes against all the ancient British/Welsh traditions about him.

reply

It's more complex than that. Arthur is not anti-Christian, he's all for peace between religions. The title of the second book, "Enemy of God", hints at the "title" given him by a few Christian fanatics and hypocrites he rubs the wrong way and who give him a bad name out of political rather than religious motives. In addition to that, Cornwell's work is based in a historical setting, ca. 500AD, well before the literary traditions that portray Arthur as a Christian king (although there's also quite a bit of literature that does not portray him as that, including in Welsh sources). Considering what we know of Christianity in the Isle of Britain in that age, it makes sense that many different religions are portrayed in the story, not just Christianity, and that Arthur is a less straightforward Christian than he appears in the literature of the later Middle Ages. There are quite a few insufferable Christians in the Warlord Chronicles, which may give some readers the overall impression that the author himself is anti-Christian. But when you read more carefully, you realize there are quite a few insufferable anythings, not just Christians! Arthur's enemies are fanatics, and they come in all shapes and colours. There are also a few good, honorable men, and these also follow different religions. It is one of the things I loved and found most interesting in his work, as opposed, for example, to the work of Marion Zimmer Bradley and her manichean Christian-bad/Pagan-good narrative (or Lawhead's Pagan-bad/Christian-good story, for that matter).

I haven't read Jack Whyte's work so thank you for the suggestion!

"Occasionally I'm callous and strange."

reply

Well if Legend of the Sword is a hit then the Warlord books will not make it to the big screen but go to TV instead. Since Game of Thrones is due to end in a couple of years, perhaps HBO see them as a replacement.

reply

Cornwell's other medieval series (The Last Kingdom) and its failure or success in terms of audience and cash might also be a factor.

"Occasionally I'm callous and strange."

reply

I'd love it. Cornwell's novels are always stirring.

reply

Other than the Sharpe books its his best work, I'd love a film adaption or HBO to pick it up!

reply

I hope this gets made! https://www.imdb.com/title/tt11716756/

And that it stays true to the books, I read them twenty years ago and they still remain his best work in my opinion.

reply