MovieChat Forums > Deadwood (2004) Discussion > Question about the guy who murdered Bill

Question about the guy who murdered Bill


I know I’m late to the party on this show but damn is it good.

So the guy that killed Bill came back in disguise and I assume he’s performing a ruse to get back at the town for the trial. But no one seems to notice him and he doesn’t seem to do get revenge. This is the only thing I don’t understand right now. Somebody would’ve remembered him by now?? Has he been gone so long?

reply

lol this confused me too. i guess they loved the actor. different character completely.

reply

wait what? I'm confused. That guy is *not* the guy that killed bill?

reply

yea...

reply

same actor but COMPLETELY different character... it was odd...

reply

Been done before....Dennis Franz did it on Hill Street Blues...

reply

Garret Dillahunt, who played Jack McCall on Deadwood came back and played Francis Wolcott, which was an entirely different character so he wasn't coming back in disguise.

Apparently the director, David Milch was known to reuse actors for various roles, especially if he liked the actor. A lot of people wouldn't necessarily pick up on the fact that it's the same actor playing two roles but people with a keen eye would easily be able to tell that.

reply

Garret Dillahunt did such a fantastic job in both rôles!

reply

It's so funny how I've recognized Garret (now) in some of his other roles. If he was a mediocre actor, I don't think he wouldn't make an impression. After watching him in Deadwood, now I see that he was the antagonist in the movie, The Last House On The Left. Besides that he was also on Justified with Timothy Olyphant.

reply

Made a quick cameo in Deadwood movie as well had a big beard.

It is the scene when the mob attack Hearst.

reply