Why? Spoilers


Why did he make her eat the apple after he just beat the *beep* out of her?

reply

He stated that his wife tried to poison him before he killed her, so he made Stella eat the apple first to make sure it wasn't poisoned.

reply

"when my wife took her lovers, she tried to poison me."
that's what he said, but we, the audience, don't know if it's true, because edgar is clearly crazy and getting worse without treatment... even his friend nick said, he'd seen it before, with the wife...
i like the way the movies presents it though, because from edgar's point of view it would look like she was sleeping with nick (he sees them in the cafe at the exact moment nick holds sella's hand)...



It's mercy, compassion and forgiveness I lack. Not rationality...

reply