MovieChat Forums > Helen of Troy (2003) Discussion > So who do you think would be the best He...

So who do you think would be the best Helen of Troy?


This board is loaded with topics comparing Guillory to Kruger, but obviously there will be many people out there who think there are better choices. Remember, Elena was supposed to be the most beautiful woman in the Greek world. The face that launched a thousand ships, and sends souls soaring in the sky, as Marlowe wrote. "With Diane Kruger, that feeling doesn't really bother me", as a professor of History recently stated.

I wonder who you guys think is the perfect actress for the role?

reply

Maybe Kate Beckinsale? Perhaps she should dye her hair blonde and wear blue or green contact lenses though.

reply

Oh, good Lord. Not another "my generic actress is prettier than your generic actress" thread. How many of these, exactly, do we need on IMDB? I also like how the above poster mentioned blonde hair and blue eyes. Yep, because EVERYONE knows that women can't be beautiful without blonde hair and blue eyes.

Are there seriously people who believe that someone can be "beautiful" to the point where it could automatically "launch a thousand ships?" If so, you are most likely a very lonely male who does not have a girlfriend due to the fact that your standards have been raised sky-high, having grown up with nothing but playboy mags stolen from pop's underwear drawer. Face it; everyone is going to look at the covergirl on some fashion magazine and think, "she's beautiful." No one is going to think "I'm going to steal her from her husband!" In the end looks come down to nothing but lumps of cartilage, flesh and melanin.

reply

Wow, that was quite a rant. And no, it's doesn't seem very plausible that a woman could be beautiful enough to launch a thousand ships. Then again, it doesn't seem very plausible that a man's only physical weakness could be the one point on his body that wasn't dipped in the Styx. It's a myth, and a rich and beautiful one in my opinion. I don't really know where Playboy came into the picture. Anyway, to the point, my pick does happen to have light hair and light eyes, but I have always pictured her as Helen, perhaps because I think she resembles Boticelli's Aphrodite. Both women, after all, are symbols of love and beauty. I go with Kate Winslet.

With every mistake, we must surely be learning.

reply

I'd say Drew Barrymore, for the same reason as the poster above says Kate Winslet. She's nowhere near the most beautiful woman in the world by today's standards, which seems to prefer exotic and angular lines, but her face is classically beautiful; lush and oval with a rosebud mouth. I think Drew, more than Kate, looks like a Boticelli painting (just look at her in Ever After!) or a Greek sculpture.

http://www.drewsmiles.com/model-05vogue.htm

reply

This is exactly what I was after. I see no appeal in Playboy models or generic beauties that are often mentioned and listed in So and So Many Prettiest Women lists... What matters is not people with a mathematically perfect face and body, but people who are beautiful through the grace of their motions and the radiation of their personality THROUGH their looks. Thanks to the two posters above for getting my point.

reply

i agree with the person above a bit further up^^^ i think kate winslet would have been perfect for the role of helen, without the british accent of course. i think sienna guillory did the part well, but i personally did not like kruger from troy much at all.

reply

plausible or not, it's only the poet's view of things
.

reply

[deleted]

In the legend, "Helen of Troy" was a natural redhead. As for beauty that "launched a thousand ships", that would depend largely upon word of mouth and through traveling fine artists and musicians. In lands ravaged by disease and servitude, those in positions of noble power were likely healthier and better dressed than the greater population. Couple those things with the faux airbrushing of being viewed by most of a population from a distance and presto: You now have a ready-made legend of divine beauty, much like the celebrity construction of stars today. All a clever individual has to do in such a position, is nurture an aura of intrigue and seduction and Helen of Troy launches a thousand ships and people are still talking about Cleopatra hundreds of years after her death (who, it must be said, became important and interesting not necessarily because she was, but because she knew how to create and cultivate her legend).

As for the significance of man-made beauty appeal, things that are created and sustain are important. If they weren't important, they wouldn't sustain. Most of the time, our task as a population is to understand why certain values are important, to define negative from positive and to look for alternatives to the negative.

reply

For some reason, I'd go for Heidi Klum... Because even in pregnancy she's still hot...

But then again in the olden days they liked their women voluptuous, so I can go for... uhhh i cant think of anyone :p

reply

i'd go for kate winslet too, but as someone above mentioned, she'd have to tone down her accent.

i thought sienna did a fantastic job as helen, but i didnt like that Troy actress.

reply

I think Nicole Kidman would be perfect. I've always thought that she was so pretty. She has an elegance that makes me think men would bow down to her. I dunno, that's just my opinion.

reply

I would only go to war for Joan Cusack.

reply

i think they should have got and actress from columbia.

reply

[deleted]

Yes, Homer describes Helen many times as a fair-skinned blonde and she is usually if not always portrayed that way in art as well.

reply

Although it is said that Helen was blonde... I think that the best option for Helen would be the bollywood queen Aishwarya Rai. She is the most beautiful woman in the world (Even Julia Roberts admited it). Many people define Ash as a Greek Goddess with an indian soul. Plus she's a brilliant actress!!!

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

I don't think there is consensus as to Helen's hair color. If there were a real Helen, I imagine she'd most likely have been brunette, perhaps influencing my list of suggested actresses:

1. Camilla Belle (Jill from "When a Stranger Calls" and Dot from "The Quiet")
2. Kristin Davis (Charlotte from "Sex and the City")
3. Famke Janssen (Dr. Jean Grey / Phoenix from "X Men" movies)

Helen was supposed to be very young, so Camilla would be the most appropriate in that sense, but I think all three have facial features that seem to fit the part.

reply