MovieChat Forums > The Station Agent (2003) Discussion > Finn and the train question. *SPOILER*

Finn and the train question. *SPOILER*


How did he survive being run over by a train???

reply

He wasn't "run over" by the train, the train ran "over" him(above him technically) so no part of the train hit him. I wouldn't recommend trying it for yourself though.

reply

Please tell a Brit..
When it was obvious the train was heading for him, my reaction was, 'He will be ok if he just flatens himself, plenty of room' .. But I live in the UK, our trains don't have 'cow catchers' on them..
Or perhaps I'm ignorant about American trains.. maybe they don't have cow catchers these days (although I though I saw one), or maybe they are set quite high. I'd like to know...

few visible scars

reply

I don't know how realistic it is for someone, even a man the size of Peter Dinklage, to be able to fit under a train, but I can tell you that trains no longer have cow catchers on the front of them. Even if they did, they would presumably have the same amount of clearance under them as the rest of the train.


"My name is Paikea Apirana, and I come from a long line of chiefs stretching all the way back to the Whale Rider."

reply

As long as we're talking about the train, I have another question. Presumably the engineer saw him, right? He made no call or anything to send someone to check?!

reply

In actuality, since I was an Engineer for BNSF, knowingly running over a person would cause me to stop the train. But, there have been instances wherein a "blanket" was continuously run over by many trains until a curious crew stopped their train and discovered a body.

It could have been that Finn was mistaken for a bundle of clothing left on the track, and I've seen a lot of bundles, junk, boxes, and other stuff on the track. The train crews are always observant and I certainly would have seen the guy's face as he watched the train approach. A train, that may be in the neighborhood of some eighteen thousand tons, won't be stopping on a dime, but perhaps a mile later after brake application.

As far as his survival, people have successfully laid flat on the ties between the rails and survived. Those that did survive were really thin people, not at all obese, and really lucky. Those locomotives are in the 480,000lb range and the 5,000gal fuel tanks are only above the rail a scant three or four inches. The worst parts are the brake pipes between the cars that sometimes are below the rail especially on autocarriers and some box cars, since they have such long and extended drawbars. With the train slack run in those brake pipes tend to hang down fairly low. Those really long hanging brake pipes have been known to drag a bit on the ties. Many trains have gone into emergency because the brake pipe glad-hand fittings hit the pavement or concrete at highway crossings and separated. Brake pipes are a heavy rubber tubing with heavy brass glad-hand fittings.

Plus, the "plow" on the engine, a heavy steel blade on the front of every engine, designed to knock things off the track that clear the rail by only a couple of inches. I've seen some plows that were just barely above the rail and regularly hit asphalt and other things especially at crossings with a really loud bang.

Then there are those fittings on tank cars, hoppers, and grain cars that may be hanging down below the rail. Many are very heavy steel or brass fittings connected by chain that may have vibrated loose or never fastened on their respective car outlet.

A fellow engineer described his nighttime horror of a woman, rejected from a homeless shelter, who committed suicide by train. She jumped in front of his train at a busy crossing and actually appeared to lean into the train as if to attempt to stop it or brace for impact. Of course, him and his conductor heard the bang when she impacted the plow. They stopped the train, ran back and found the woman with a leg separated at the hip, knocked off the rail and lying a few feet alongside the right-of-way. Of course, she never survived.

Bottom line, never allow yourself to be run "over" by a train with you between the rails...


reply

I was not considering it.

Schrodinger's cat walks into a bar, and / or doesn't.

reply

Thanks for your answer.

reply