MovieChat Forums > Girl with a Pearl Earring (2004) Discussion > QUESTION: tile her father gave her and ...

QUESTION: tile her father gave her and ones in studio?


I'm sure this has been asked, but can someone explain the tile Griet's father gave her before she left home?

He made that (or painted it anyway), right? Okay -- so then what was the connection to the same types of tiles she noticed along the baseboards when she moved the chair in the studio?

Was that to imply Vermeer had bought some of Griet's father's tiles? Maybe someone who has read the book can explain the significance here.

Thanks,
Jane

reply

[deleted]

I too wondered about the significance or connection of the tiles. How did Griet let on that the tiles were not painted by her father. Were these sort of paintings common in 17th century Netherlands?

reply

[deleted]

I wondered about this as well. Feel like it should have been left out if they weren't going to explain it. I read the reply comments to the OP's question but I'm still confused on why this was added to the movie.

reply

[deleted]

In the book Griet has a younger brother and sister. By the end of the book, the brother has run away from Delft because, having become an apprentice tile painter, he hates the work and doesn't want to follow in his father's career path; and the sister has died.

The tile shows a boy and a girl who are supposed to be Griet and her brother. For Griet, who has had to leave home to work, it evokes memories of when her family was together and not desperately poor. When Cornelia breaks the tile, it's a fresh reminder to Griet that her family is broken: her sister dead, she and her brother gone away to find work.

Without the brother and sister in the movie to provide context, there's almost no point in even having any scenes with the tile, except to show Cornelia being bratty again.

There is no implication that Griet's father painted the Vermeers' tiles. The book even says that Griet looks for tiles painted by her father but doesn't see any.

The tiles don't symbolize anything. They have a practical purpose: so that when the housewife or maid mops the floor, the water won't damage the paint on the walls.

reply

In one of Vermeer's painting (in real life), a string of tiles can be seen on the floor, leaning on the wall.
They are positioned just like in the movie.

I think the painting is The Milkmaid.

reply