This movie incorrectly paints all Christians as...
(1) Homophobic
(2) Anti-Semitic
(3) Vandals
(4) Haters of pregnant teens
(5) Narcissistic
(6) Haters of the handicapped
(7) Liars
(8) Hallucinogenic
(9) Psychopathic
I understand what the producers were attempting to do with the whole "hypocrisy" angle, but at the same time, they sent a horrible message to the world. Mandy Moore's character was too over the top and she played a ridiculous, cartoonish "Christian Everyman."
I totally got a lot of the humor, but a lot of the other situations just fell flat. What they did here was support the stereotype of a small percent of Christians. By weight of comparison, it would be like the producers making a lengthy film about black people eating watermelon and fried chicken and having no positive traits whatsoever.
Sadly, we live in a time where it's "hip" to bash Christians and this movie is just one item in a long line of subtle attacks.