MovieChat Forums > 11:14 (2004) Discussion > MAGNOLIA RIP-OFF!!!

MAGNOLIA RIP-OFF!!!


Father daughter relationship, with protective father and troubled daughter- check
ensemble cast- check
fate's a bitch, or whatever lesson u want to take- check
*beep* up clerk(hillary swank-william h macy. and her role was originally written for a guy) - check
good guy dumbie cop- check

I'm sure there are literally a million 0ther similarities but im too bored to type it up and am in fact offended by the blatant theft. ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY NOM!! NOW! NOW! NOW NOW NOW!!!

reply

Ridiculous argument - check!
Blatant disregard for grammar - check!

reply

Everything that you stated was so vauge.
That could describe a lot of movies.

haha

I can't even believe you actually are so intense about this, are you serious?

I hope your kidding, if not than that's pretty sad.

reply

I can't really see how Magnolia and 11:14 are even remotely similar, but have you seen a film called Short Cuts (1993)? Now, Magnolia could definitely be called a rip-off of that one! So, who's ripping off who??

reply

No movies are completely original. - check
People have a tendency to think their introduction to a plot or trope is the definition of it. - check
People then come on the internet to complain when they see another film using this plot or trope. - check
All the while not realizing that the film they are so vehemently defending likely "ripped off" something else that came before it. - check

reply