Marta's liberation


This movie is fantastic for its subtlety. So much is left for the viewer to interpret and speculate. There are especially 3 points that are left to the imagination (1) what did Jacobo give Marta as a present at the end of the film, (2) what happened between Marta and Herman in the hotel room, and (3) what did the note to Herman say. Obviously, no one can say for sure, but I do not believe that Marta and Herman started up some sort of affair in Piriapolis and that she then ran off to be with him in Brazil. Remember that Herman was already married with teenage daughters. I suspect that his wife is still in the picture because of the phone call Marta got when she was in Jacobo's apartment. The voice on the other end was speaking Portuguese. Also, I think that Marta was too old for that kind of frivolity. She yearned for romance, but I don't think it would have been in her character to run off with a married man.

The hotel room: I think that Marta told Herman that the marriage was a sham when she visited Herman in the hotel room. I think she also told him that she wanted to go to Brazil, not because she wanted to be with him necessarily, but because she wanted to get out of her current life. I suspect this because after the hotel room scene, Marta tells Herman in the pastry store that if she could travel, she would like to go to Brazil. This would not make sense to Herman unless he KNEW that she had never been there before. Recall that Jacobo and Marta lied to Herman that they spent their honeymoon in Brazil. But Herman does not question her when she says that, which suggests that he knew that the honeymoon story, and the marriage, was false.

The gift: I think that Jacobo gave Marta money. He intended to do that all along, even though Marta declined it. This is supported by the fact that the Jacobo won a large sum of money playing roulette. It was the only time he cracked a smile during the whole film. The package looked like it could contain a large sum of money, and I think that Marta confirmed her decision to leave when she received it. Watch her expression in the cab as she is riding home holding the package. The gift is her key to freedom.

The note: This is the most obscure part of the film. What did that note say? I suspect it said something to the effect of "I'm leaving Jacobo's business and leaving Uruguay. I will be travelling to Brazil and will look you up when I get there." Alternatively, it could be a "Thank you." It must be something that Marta did not want Herman to know about until it was too late for him to communicate it to Jacobo.

These are only possible interpretations. I would like to hear other people's. Isn't it great when you can debate these kinds of subtleties from a film? So refreshing from the usual American-made trype.

reply

Certainly and mazing movie. I think i am quite agree with you about Marta's destiny and definitivly think she told him in the hotel room it was all a lie.

reply

I don't think the note revealed the truth about the "marriage". Marta does not seem like the type of woman who would do such an unkind thing to her boss who was depending on her to keep up the false front.
And I don't believe Marta ran away at the end. I felt that she would eventually show up to work. After the initial surprise at not seeing Marta at the facorty gate, Jacobo didn't seem alarmed that Marta was not there because he knew she would show up...eventually.

reply

Boy you really missed the boat! I suggest you watch this movie again. You completely missed the point. Geez.

reply

It's not very helpful when a user says how wonderful it is to be able to "debate" the outcome of a movie, and then criticizes another user for responding to his Post in a way he disagrees with.

I think something happened in the hotel room. There was definitely awkwardness at the breakfast table the next morning. Marta mentioned to Hermano that she wanted to go to Brazil, and she was hoping Hermano would extend an invitation. But he simply says that Brazil is a beautiful country, but does not encourage her to visit him.

I'm torn about Marta's fate, and I don't know if she will ever show up to work at the factory again. With the money Jacobo gave her, she could start a new life; but I have a hard time believing someone like Marta would have to courage to do so. In the taxi, we see her debating what has probably been the most exciting weekend of her uneventful life. She doesn't know what to do next, and so it is impossible for us as the audience to guess.

Just my views....

reply

It's not very helpful when a user says how wonderful it is to be able to "debate" the outcome of a movie, and then criticizes another user for responding to his Post in a way he disagrees with.

LOL, that's very true. The OP should also take his own advice, coz the answer to question 1 was clear in the movie. (He wrapped up cash. We just don't know how much).

As for the bedroom, whether they had sex or not is only important to the brother's character. It's clear that Marta went there with that intention. She's been in love with Jacobo for years, and has now finally given up on him.

I doubt Jacobo ever saw Marta again. She now knows that there is no chance that the two of them will ever be an item, and is off to pastures new with the cash.

Jacobo is as oblivious at the end as he was at the beginning. He still thinks nothing at all about Marta as an individual, and he just takes it for granted that she'll be back. But she won't be.


reply

He certainly gives her the bulk of the money. When he bring the money to the casino it's in a small yellow envelope, when he wins it back, clearly 32 times the amount, he brings it back in the same envelope (larger denomination notes, or else the packet would have been 32 times larger!)

He takes off a few notes and pockets them - probably his original stake, which will pay for the Italian machines and whatnot - and gives the rest to her. Which is a lovely scene.

Whilst I like open and ambiguous endings, I did find this one unnecessarily open. It would have been nice to know what happened!

As far as all the conjecturing above, who knows. She could have had a heart-attack when she saw all that money (which is obviously 31 times what was initially a lot of money).

My guess is that she saw the money, and decided that she wasn't going to go back to work again as she didn't need to. Or perhaps would pop by later to hand in her notice and Jacobo guessed this would happen. No idea!

As for the contents of the note, again, it's anyone's guess. You could all be right! :-)

reply

to (1) I Think he gives her the money. And then she goes to Brasil to meet with Hermann

reply


Yeah I agree that he gives her the money. But I think she goes to Brazil, but not with the intention to meet him:
cant remember the exact words
"I have always wanted to go to Brazil."
"It is a very beautiful place, but I am never there, always travelling."
In my head I seemed to see something that was like "oh" in her eyes and head. We have to remember that Herman seems happily married and in love with his family too.
I think she went to Brazil, but to start a new life and to have an adventure.

Lovely movie, watched it for the first time today as I happened to be home and it was on film4 (uk) Count it as one of my favourites now.

reply

I think your answer fits best, she did not seem to me to run off and meet the brother in Brazil. I don't know how that was even a thought to viewers. I believe as you she just wanted to have some fun. she may have returned after a while to help the out. He did show kindness in giving her the money, so why would she betray him and not be kind in return.

reply

Running away with Hermann? Meeting Hermann in Brazil?? People!! You should watch the entire movie again 'cause you obviously missed somes scenes.

reply

what did they miss?

reply