MovieChat Forums > Mystic River (2003) Discussion > Okay, I'll just come out and say it...SP...

Okay, I'll just come out and say it...SPOILERS!!


Why didn't Jimmy go to jail for killing Dave?

reply

Why didn't Jimmy go to jail for killing Dave?


People don't get indicted and convicted on a hunch or hearsay, they get convicted on evidence. What evidence was there to convict Jimmy? The only witnesses were his goons, and in all likelihood Dave's body was never even found.

reply

The OP may be referring to Jimmy pretty much admitting he killed Dave to Sean (the Cop) But Sean probably felt some loyalty to an old friend and felt bad that he suffered enough with his daughter getting murdered.

reply

Makes me wonder what Sean's finger-gun pointing at Jimmy means. Even if he decides to pursue it, what does he have? He said/he said on something vague to begin with, "if only you'd found 'em a little sooner." OK, maybe not so vague, but completely uncorroborated. No body. No crime scene. A wife feeling guilty for being complicit, so she's gonna clam up.

reply