MovieChat Forums > Swimming Upstream (2003) Discussion > Anyone NOT like this movie?

Anyone NOT like this movie?


Please do not kill me about what I'm about to post. But I'm just wondering did anyone not like this film? I didn't like it very much, I found it quite boring. Actaully everyone in my class found it boring.

reply

I'm not going to kill you, but I thought it was great. Great acting, great story, great realism.

My Dad said it looked and felt like his own childhood - minus the Olympics, of course.

Well, if it makes you feel better, everyone I know thinks Picnic At Hanging Rock is excellent, but I think I wasted two hours of my life. It's just people's opinions.



I may not agree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.
ii:iv

reply

I watched this a while ago, and at the first viewing, turned it off after about 30 minutes - thought the acting was terrible and the script even worse. But a friend who'd watched it all the way through persuaded me to give it another try, which I did - and found it to be the best Aussie film I've ever seen. Geoffrey Rush is magnificent (as he tends to be), but principally, the two boys (Jesse Spencer and Tim Draxl) are just superb. Knowing that the story is true, exacerbated by the recent drama surrounding Di Fingleton, made it poignant and disturbingly true to life for all of us.

Loved this movie - a 10/10.

reply

I adore it. I think it is incredibly powerful.

It's a Geoffrey Rush thing, you wouldn't understand!

reply

I found that watching movies at school can suck all the fun out of it, especially when you know you have to do stuff on it afterwards. We had to do stuff for Rabbit Proof Fence in Australian Studies last year and I wouldn't mind taking the class again if I could do something for Swimming Upstream.

--
Cats don’t come when called. They take a message and get back to you later.

reply

I thought it ws very good. The story was so moving and inspiring.

Geoffrey Rush = Incredible
"Pritchett was right, the house is alive" - House on Haunted Hill 1999

reply

I'm with the OP. This movie is terrible.

reply

Very boring movie. I tried to watch 15 mins and i had to give up.


The best multiplayer internet football (soccer) game: [ulr]
http://soccer.kiekko.tk/
[/url]

reply

on the level of a made-for-tv movie. facile characters

awful dad, wonderful kids & mom, sibling rivalry.

seemed like a cartoon.

reply

Very early I sensed this was a tale that was made in the editing room. It was just too slick for me to work as compelling drama. I also disliked both parents immediately. The film was perhaps too perfect looking to portray a dysfunctional family. A little more grit would have been welcome.

reply