MovieChat Forums > Herushingu (2003) Discussion > Alucard vs. Lucy or Mariko (from Elfen L...

Alucard vs. Lucy or Mariko (from Elfen Lied)?

posted 13 years ago by simpsoniac12-169-518891
2 replies | jump to latest

As I watched the anime series it amazed me at how "unbeatable" Alucard was against his foes. Whenever he does his demonic power up, he would overcome his enemies with a more frightening physical appearance than the last. Then I started thinking to myself of what would happen if he crossed paths with the queen Diclonius, Lucy. I'm not only referring to Lucy from the anime series, but Lucy from the later volumes of the manga series where she developed more vectors. Now when I refer to Lucy as "Lucy", let's just pretend that Nyu does not exist. I want it to be the malicious genocidal freak of nature against the sadistic vampire-slaying demon of the night. I don't know how it will go but I would pick Alucard because he relishes in these violent showdown moments. Who would you pick? If Lucy is not much of a choice then how about Mariko as a substitute? Also, why not Anderson versus either Lucy or Mariko?

[–] akira_2108 12 years ago

It is a tough one.

Mariko I think would not win because she would be too scared and can't take pain as well. Also her vector strength isn't as great as Lucy and and extent in manga.

Honestly I think if we are talking about anime Lucy, Alucard would win. He would not even have to release his restrictions. The casul gun being 0.5 anti-tank calibre would knock her for 6 at close range although probably not enough to finish her and in that case the jackall would blast right through her - it is just way too powerful for the vectors to block.

No question Lucy would 'kill' Alucard a few times if he gets in range or she throws stuff at him but given how that would not destroy him permanently he would most likely regenerate. I imagine it being like when he fought Walter - he unleashes Baskerville and he rips it apart but while doing so, Alucard sneaks up on him and (fails) fires the jackall from behind.

The manga Lucy is more like a nuclear weapon of mass destruction(in the final culmination) - it depends on whether Alucard is capable of phasing through the vectors like he does through walls - in that case he could just bypass her vectors and tear out her heart.

[–] HorrorMonkey 12 years ago

My money would be on Alucard. Why?

They could all spend the whole fight tearing eachother apart, but Alucard would be the only one capable of reforming himself. Lucy and Mariko may have their horns and vectors, but take them away and they are hardly better than a normal human.

"I have NEEDS now, Alfred - dirty, horrible needs!" -- Batman