MovieChat Forums > Sam gang (2002) Discussion > So what really happened in the end

So what really happened in the end


Great third segment to Three, but the ending has me baffled? **Spoilers**
So what happened? Did the wife really wake up. Who is the girl in red?

reply

S
P
O
I
L
E
R
.
.
.
Yes, the wife really did revive. But then died again. Perhaps she needed immediate care/medicine? The girl in Red was the ghost of the child they aborted.
The part I do not understand is the photographers studio. Was that the afterworld? Was the boy dead? When he left the studio, did he return to the world of the living, or was he, like the girl, now a ghost?

reply

The wife chose to give up her life because her beloved husband is dead.
The coffin is for the cop in case he is dead, however the husband though it is for his wife so he ran after that coffin vehicle.
That is such a touching scene.
I also got the problem about the photographers studio. I guess it is not a real world. It is the place where the ghoasts(the little girl) and spirits(when the husband was nursed by his wife when he got cancer)stays.
The little boy get into that space that is why he couldnt be found in the real world.
Since it doesnt belong to the real world, he probably just stayed there for several minutes, however it might has been several days in the outside world.

reply

> Since it doesnt belong to the real world, he probably just stayed there for
> several minutes, however it might has been several days in the outside world.

Thanks for that interpretation, I was sad thinking the boy had to be dead. Perhaps he was reunited with his father after all.

reply

The coffin is for the cop in case he is dead, however the husband though it is for his wife so he ran after that coffin vehicle.

No, she was in the coffin, that is when she revived, he saw it, shocked, was ran over and killed, she chose not to go on and repeat the 3 yr process caring for him again, this is why, at the end in the photography studio, they are all together now all dead. The boy is not, that is why he walks out.

reply

agree with your assesment...

reply

[deleted]

< lots of SPOILERS >
.
.
.
I read the story slightly differently to the other people here. Here's my interpretation.

The little girl in red is the aborted child of the husband and wife. The photographer's studio is a sort of 'netherworld' between life and death. When we see the father alone with the daughter at the beginning, it is during the period when he was 'dead' and recovering from a tumour. Now the husband is back in the real world, but the daughter is left, unwilling to continue through to the world of the dead without her parents.

The girl in red leads the son away from his policeman father, and hides him in the photographer's shop / 'netherworld' because she wants the policeman to visit her father and stop him reviving her mother: at least then she'll have one parent with her. In the end, she gains both parents, since the father is killed and, as a consequence, the mother sees no reason to fully revive, and allows herself to die, also. We see the three of them reunited at the photography shop, presumably on their way to eternity together.

The only thing which complicates this slightly is that the girl had not been aborted during the father's time 'dead', if I remember correctly. I think this is reflected in the fact that she is not photographed with him, and does not speak to the photographer (who comments on her silence). She is, in this first scene, a 'person in potential', in a sense: an echo of a future ghost, who only comes into true being when her mother falls ill, and hence by the time the policeman and his son move into the block of flats. (The fact that the girl is the only true ghost might also explain why she wanders around outside the photographer's shop, whilst the mother does not.)

reply

Testoll said" The coffin is for the cop in case he is dead, however the husband though it is for his wife so he ran after that coffin vehicle."

No, she was in the coffin, and he saw her move, that is when she revived, he saw it, shocked, (because remember this was his first time seeing one of them revived, he was the first victim) was ran over and killed, she chose not to go on and repeat the 3 yr process caring for him again, she states this by saying for the dead it is 3 yrs long sleep for the living it is a daily heartbreak this is why, at the end in the photography studio, they are all together now all dead. The boy is dead too, when you see the drawing on the wall at first, it is just the girl, then after he disappears it is him and her on the wall, this shows you he is now where she was (dead).

reply

Ok, so, how did he die?

reply

I think the girl was aborted prior to the father's "death". They found were diagnosed with cancer at about the same time. The father probably went first because he was further along or maybe he just didn't want to endanger his wife in case it didn't work.

I also think the boy did not die. The kid had some sort of Sixth Sense deal going on as he was the only person who saw the girl in the real world. She was in the real world as a ghost rather than going off to the afterlife because she wanted to be with her parents (the mom's soul was still in her body; that's why the father talked to it everyday). The kid enters the barbershop which is a nexus of sorts between the worlds. When he leaves at the end we see him look back and the door of the barber shop is no longer there.

reply

I think the wife died at the end because she needed her husband to keep her soul alive by speaking to her but he had stopped because he was taken away and then later struck and killed.

reply

I'm inclined to agree with the "potential person" idea. Remember, we're specifically told that the father was strongly opposed to having an abortion (perhaps because he had already seen the child during his time in the netherworld?)

Basically, a great film. I might give it a second look tomorrow before I return the DVD, although I did notice one mild logical flaw;
When the Doctor was giving his speeches about Chinese medicine, etc. trying to explain that he isn't crazy and his wife really will awake, why didn't he ever mention that he'd already been resurrected himself?

reply

'When the Doctor was giving his speeches about Chinese medicine, etc. trying to explain that he isn't crazy and his wife really will awake, why didn't he ever mention that he'd already been resurrected himself?'

I thought something similar as the police guy sussed it all out after watching the video after they had both died. He was shown the video before the guy died when he was tied to the TV but he was more interested in getting away and looking for his son so missed the whole video story bit. I think that was his way to tell it as he would have thought he was mad if he had said I was dead for 3 years and my wife resurrected me...?

reply

I guess I'm the only one who interpreted it the way I did. I thought the little girl's tie to this world was connected to the mother's. The husband was talking to the wife every day to keep her soul in her body, and if she died when she was pregnant then it makes sense that the soul of the fetus didn't cross over, either. It made me suspect that there was going to be a plot twist where we find out that she didn't have time to get an abortion before she died, but I turned out to be wrong.

I still suspect I was on to something and perhaps the little girl's soul was still spiritually tied to the mother's body despite the abortion. I haven't quite put the pieces together but it seems to me that the husband's actions to keep the wife's soul behind is somehow connected to the little girl being earthbound, too. But not quite in the same way, since she can walk around and is even growing up while the wife is just sitting there dead.

Maybe she started to cross over, but then the husband's measures to keep his wife's soul behind also prevented the little girl from fully crossing over, too. Possibly because of some bodily and/or spiritual connection between the mother and the fetus. I'm not sure, I can't quite put my finger on it and make all the pieces fit together. Maybe I need to watch it a second time.

reply

Going home was amazing. Glad I found it on netflix

reply

The boy was always a ghost. He was a ghost from the very first introduction of the film.

The 'barbershop' is a photography studio. It is not a 'nexus of worlds'. The symbolism is related to myths that pictures capture the soul/spirit/essence of a person. The entire point of this symbolism is to make you think the boy is/and always has been a ghost once you link it back to the girl in red dress in the opening.

You are also incorrect about that last bit. The boy leaves the photography studio and looks back. There is kanji on the door, but I don't know what it says, but I'm pretty sure the long shot of this glass door with kanji on it and the boy in the background is to relay the message on the door which will summarize the tale, and directly explain the son. I'm sure it says something along the lines of "Capture the loving spirit of your family for always!"

reply

The girl in the red dress is the unborn daughter Yu and his wife lost. The little boy...has always been a ghost from the outset of the story. He died prior to everything that takes place in the film. He can't move on because his father can't let go.

According to the film, letting go is beneficial to both the one that passes on and the living left behind. Otherwise both parties become trapped and can no longer pass on or move forward. This is evident at the end of the film, when the son is still lurking unnoticed in the photographers studio. He is a ghost who is sustained by his father's (the cop) inability to let go.

Alternately, there is a similar mythology built up around traditional medicine. Yu sustains his wife's spirit and keeps it rooted to her body while it heals.

I guess both Yu and the cop were doing the same thing, but in different ways. I'm disappointed that more of a parallel wasn't drawn between the characters and their circumstances while Yu had the cop confined.

reply