MovieChat Forums > Sam gang (2002) Discussion > Rank the three stories!

Rank the three stories!


Here's mine!

1) Memories
2) Going Home

































3) The Wheel

reply

1) Going home

2) The wheel - The story seemed really bad, but the ending was great. It was all a vision, but he got the chance to change it; but he didn't. Great!

3) Memories - The beginning was very interesting, but the story was too obvious and unrelated.

reply

[deleted]

Going Home (best by far)
Memories (nothing special)
The Wheel (worst by far)

reply

[deleted]

The Wheel was terrible, the other two were great. "Going Home" is my favorite

reply

[deleted]

1. Going Home-(fantastic. 4.5/5)
2. Memories-(creepy start, then slowly fades away into tedium. 2.5/5)
3. The Wheel-(utter garbage. 0/5)

What do you mean no ice?? You're telling me I have to drink this coffee hot?

reply

1. Going Home - great all round and superb ending I didn't see coming
2. Memories - OK but to obvious
3. The Wheel - Unfortunately like many Thai ghost/scary films their culture and ghost stories don't always translate well. I did like the ending nice little twist but the rest was drab to get there.

reply

1) Memories - I just like "jump moments"... this was the only story with any in it.
2) Going Home - Great story.
3) The Wheel - Felt kinda lost in the translation (if you will).

reply

1) Going Home - Effective and surprising touching (though the whole photographer part lost me a little).
2) Memories - The only truly scary one of the three.
3) The Wheel - Has it's moments but the premise was a lot better than the final film.

--------------------------------
"Why are you wearing that stupid man suit?"

reply

1. Going Home 10/10

2. Memories 7/10

3. The Wheel 5/10


Overall: 7/10


reply