MovieChat Forums > The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003) Discussion > I'll always love how this movie did a nu...

I'll always love how this movie did a number on that clown Roger Ebert.


Some snippets of his review of the movie. Cracks me up.

The new version of "The Texas Chainsaw Massacre" is a contemptible film: Vile, ugly and brutal. There is not a shred of a reason to see it. Those who defend it will have to dance through mental hoops of their own devising, defining its meanness and despair as "style" or "vision" or "a commentary on our world." It is not a commentary on anything, except the marriage of slick technology with the materials of a geek show.


There is no worthy or defensible purpose in sight here: The filmmakers want to cause disgust and hopelessness in the audience. Ugly emotions are easier to evoke and often more commercial than those that contribute to the ongoing lives of the beholders.


This movie, strewn with blood, bones, rats, fetishes and severed limbs, photographed in murky darkness, scored with screams, wants to be a test: Can you sit through it? There were times when I intensely wanted to walk out of the theater and into the fresh air and look at the sky and buy an apple and sigh for our civilization, but I stuck it out. The ending, which is cynical and truncated, confirmed my suspicion that the movie was made by and for those with no attention span.


"The Texas Chainsaw Massacre" doesn't want to exorcise anything. It wants to tramp crap through our imaginations and wipe its feet on our dreams.


This movie is made with venom and cynicism. I doubt that anybody involved in it will be surprised or disappointed if audience members vomit or flee.

Do yourself a favor. There are a lot of good movies playing right now that can make you feel a little happier, smarter, sexier, funnier, more excited -- or more scared, if that's what you want. This is not one of them. Don't let it kill 98 minutes of your life.

https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/the-texas-chainsaw-massacre-2003

reply

Ebert is right, this remake is utter SHITE. The IMDb rating says so.

However, when he trashed Gladiator, that I did NOT agree with.

reply

Ebert was a clown and a pussy. This remake is stellar. So brutal it had poor Roger shook.

You can't judge a movie by it's IMDb rating. IMDb users are a small sample size and prone to bias (most IMDb users are american white males between 25-45 who identify as 'cinephiles', i.e, they're a touch snobby). In any case a 6.2 is a great rating for a horror movie, especially a remake that gets it's share of hate from people who see it as a competitor to their nostalgic original. Many people were set against this movie before they even saw it.

reply