I'd say this is more of a tragi-comedy, funny but not "hilarious," though that is NOT necessarily a flaw by any means. There are MANY levels of humor, levels that transcend our English-language synonyms, and some of the tamest of which can, every now and again, be the most satisfying (as in this film). But, alas, "hilarious" (implying fast-paced, gut-busting burlesque) seems to be the catch-all buzzword that is attached to any film with the slightest hint of humor, which, unfortunately, leads to great films like this being mis-marketed, slammed by viewers who were expecting something else, while scaring off the people who were looking for something subtler.
Don't get me wrong! I don't think anyone is wrong NOT to like this film. Different people have different tastes that have nothing to do with intelligence (take from an English PhD candidate who never misses South Park)
Of course, the cultural difference has a great deal to do with it as well. I'm an American, and, unfortunately, if it doesn't have Adam Sandler slobbering around with a feigned speech impediment or Rob Schneider in drag (cross-dressing for the sake of cross-dressing having become quite a prominent and overused cliche in the American cinema for the past five years [e.g. Juwanna Mann, Sorority Boys, The Hot Chick, Big Mamma's House, and others I can't bear to mention ], then MARKETING over here doesn't consider it comedy.
(of course, I'm making generalizations. There are outstanding American comedies, some of which are indeed "hilarious" -- sadly, they aren't PROMOTED correctly)
reply
share