MovieChat Forums > My House in Umbria (2003) Discussion > A MADE FOR T.V. HAPPY ENDING

A MADE FOR T.V. HAPPY ENDING


In the William Trevor novella Aimee does go to America with her uncle at the end, for a dismal future. The movie provides a happy- if not altogther plausible- ending.

Blaine in Seattle

reply

Well, there's a possibility that it wasn't reality. Did you notice how when Aimee came back and opened her curtains, it was all kind of slow an diffused with light? I had the impression that perhaps it was Ms Delahunty's way of dealing with the loss of yet another person she cares about. She certainly had a "psychic" dream showing the little girl's possible future, and her dreams mostly turned out to be true. So maybe this was her coping mechanism, to create the perfect outcome.

"You shouldn't have hit me with that!... You'll ruin the cake!" - Greybags

reply

Indeed. You're right. Throughout the film she's retelling history in fictionalized terms and the ending appears to be her coping mechanism view of how things might have been rather than the more harsh reality of the lives of all involved.

reply

We are not supposed to take the film's ending literally. As the film is ending, Maggie Smith is explaining directly to the audience that *in her books* there is always a happy ending for lovers and children. She is creating her own ending for Aimee.

reply