MovieChat Forums > American Idol: The Search for a Superstar (2002) Discussion > A Girl has NEVER won AI since Jennifer L...

A Girl has NEVER won AI since Jennifer Lopez became a Judge..


isn't that ironic?

ever since she became a judge, a girl has never won.

But when Mariah took over for a season, it was a final 5 girls...funny 🐷

reply

Because J Ho was jealous of the superior-talented girls and systematically brought them down with her ridiculous critiques (coughHaleycough)!

reply

Mariah was a great judge! too bad Nicki spoiled it

reply

Are you joking? Mariah was terrible. And this is coming from a fan of hers.

reply