MovieChat Forums > Elf (2003) Discussion > This movie was not considered to be anyt...

This movie was not considered to be anything special in 2003


I know in recent years its found an audience and some people are calling it a classic. But back then a lot of people thought it was pretty terrible. Yes it made money but it wasn't thought of anything other than a crude comedy (and there was many of them in the early 2000's). I'm honestly surprised how many people well regard this movie these days. Maybe it vibes better with the culture now as far as humor.

reply

Well when you wanna get together with friends and watch a movie in December, preferably a Christmas movie, and preferably a funny movie, there aren't that many options. This is one of those few options.

Christmas movies are a league of their own because people rewatch these things year after year

reply

That's not really true. I saw it in the theater when it was new, and remember it being very popular and well-received. Perhaps critics didn't like it? That I don't recall, but I do that it was generally being spoken of as a "new Christmas classic" even while it was still in its initial theatrical run.

reply

uh I liked it just as much in 2003 as i do now, and I'm sure many did. It only got even bigger now because more than 1 generation of fans has seen it now and like it, and it's easier for people to give it a chance on stuff like Netflix now rather than buying a ticket to see it at the movies.

reply

I remember it getting mixed reviews in 2003. Lots of people I knew went to go see it though.

reply