MovieChat Forums > Because of Winn-Dixie (2005) Discussion > The Downside of Popular Dog Movies

The Downside of Popular Dog Movies


Unfortunately a lot of the time when a dog movie is popular the breed of dog that's in the movie becomes a "fad" leading to many people getting that type of dog without researching it and figuring out if it's best for their lifestyle. This in turn encourages many inexperienced dog breeders to breed unhealthy dogs in order to make money off that breed. The Jack Russell Terrier (a very energetic and sometimes hard to control breed) experienced this problem after being popularized by "Frasier" and "My Dog Skip". Hopefully that won't happen with this movie.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Well, I would hope that people aren't that stupid, scorpio, but I guess you never know..

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Yeah I have to agree with this. Border Collie fad, albeit small, happened after Babe came out. I'll even admit that was ONE of the determining factors of which dog I chose at the pound. It came down to a German Shep. or a Border and I chose the Border because I thought they were adorable, intelligent animals. Plus, she was on death row - sentenced to be euthanized by the end of the week because she was at the shelter for over two months, meanwhile the Shep had a chance because he knew every command (even hand signals) and had only been there for two days. Then we got home and found out that because of her instinct to run and herd she had gone neurotic being locked up for so long in a small kennel. We've kept her though, we have a lot of problems with her taking off and not listening to commands, but we still love her and would do anything for her. It just sucks. But I agree, the fad thing isn't right and I feel terrible that was even one of the glimmers of thought in the back of my head when I got my dog.

reply

This is the kindest and most humane board I have come across on this particular site. I have not seen this movie because, in all honesty, I cannot watch a move if the dog dies—and I don’t know whether Winn-Dixie lives or dies. Tears my heart out if the dog dies. Anyway, I have never had a dog that was not a “mutt” or a rescue. I still miss my little girl Hank, who died almost three years ago. She was the runt of the litter and not expected to live past a couple of months. She was 12 when she died. I now have 2 girls—Gracie and Sadie. Gracie was in the shelter and due to be put down in 48 hours. She’s one of those hyper, needs-much-attention pups that most people can’t put in the time with. She was adopted and returned twice (adopted apparently because she’s a pretty girl). We’ve had her for almost 3 years now and I can’t imagine not having her. She’s still energetic and aggravating at times, but she’s a complete sweetheart and extremely smart. All she needed was some training and a lot of love and patience. I found Sadie while working on a litigation prep project at a now-defunct uranium mine in nowhere New Mexico. She was just a baby, but filthy and starved and running with a pack of almost-wild dogs in a place with no real accessible food and water, but she didn’t seem ready to give up. I loved her the second I met her. I was told that when she showed up at the site, she actually collapsed from apparent starvation. Well, she came home with me. She needed more medical attention than a lot of dogs, but we have a fantastic vet who took great care of her. She’s now healthy, well-fed, very much loved, and very comfortable in her home. She’s a little cuddle bug and I couldn’t love her more. She’s not a beautiful dog in the sense that most people look for, but her heart is what counts. Our dogs are our family—the kind of family that we wouldn’t leave a burning house without. The point in all of this—and I realize it’s long—is that pets are not fads or fashion accessories. A dog is not a Prada handbag or a fancy pair of running shoes that you can toss in the back of the closet because it’s out of fashion in 6 months. It angers and hurts me that people treat animals as such. But in this world, anyone can have a child or a pet without any particular qualification. I don’t have a suggestion as to how to change that at this point…but give me time.

reply

[deleted]

Thanks for the heads (or "tails") up, Benji. I haven't had a chance to see it yet, but I hope to, soon. I'll let you know!

reply

Not to mention the fact that with Easter coming up, lots of irresponsible folks think chicks or bunnies would make "cute pets in the Easter basket" without thinking of the long-term.

In the Winn-Dixie book, the dog was actually an Irish Wolfhound. Thank goodness they didn't cast the breed - can you imagine trendy apartment-dwellers running out to buy one? Yikes!!

reply

One word: "dalmatians"

reply