Victor is unlikeable


Here's a nice, arguable topic...is Victor Vargas a character who is appealing and likeable enough to carry a movie?

I think not, and here's why. His ways have made him become lost, and finally he meets a girl who he actually feels something for. There's nothing wrong about a lost character...in fact, most of the great cinema characters are lost in some way. The problem with Victor is that he's one of those guys who is so busy proliferating an image that he misses what's truly important in life. I found it difficult to like a character who's confusion and angst are not even remotely backed up by any redeeming qualities.

In some movies, this kind of character is strategically used. Look at "American Psycho" or "A Clockwork Orange" where the decidedly unlikeable character is used to show something, in these cases, about where society is headed.

Anyway, Victor is not a strong enough character to carry a movie. He'd make a nice supporting character in an urban drama, but in a character study- there's gotta be a more appealing character!

reply

I can see where you are comming from. At the beginning of the movie I hated his character. But I think he undergows a realistic change and becomes very likealbe. After re-watching the movie, I thought his actions which originally made him so unlikealbe were sort of endearing. It's funny because he's so pathetic. You see that he is just trying to build up his image and that he is not really a jerk like some of the other guys who are constantly tormenting Judy.

reply

Yeah he definitely could have been a lot worse. Yes, he's very pathetic, but for some reason, I didn't care to stick with him through his change. I think the movie would have been better if told from a poignant perspective of the younger brother. What do you think?

reply

nope. I thought it was right the way it was

"...I'm a contradiction"

reply

[deleted]


Exactly. Victor's unlikeable to Judy, even to his grandmother because he is growing up. His adolescence makes him adopt an apalling swagger that he thinks is cool. But his love for Judy makes him strain for adulthood, and the moments he loses that awful swagger--showing Judy the baby chick, buying her a toy from the vending machine and changing her view of the handicapped toy figure to a man on wheels, apologizing and inviting her to dinner, finally admitting who he is--transforms him so that at the end you have a real person named Victor who has proven that Judy can trust him if she wants to grow up.

Watch it again.

reply

Very well said, exactly perfect.

reply

no i didn't like his personality either. the characters around him is what makes the movie for me. mainly the grandmother.



reply