MovieChat Forums > La hija del caníbal (2003) Discussion > REVIEW ER is WRONG! MOVIE IS AWESOME!

REVIEW ER is WRONG! MOVIE IS AWESOME!


WEll, I do not understand WHY the reviewer thinks there is no emotion in this movie, MAYBE it is a CULTURAL thing, and this main-stream american critic is not up to the challenge. I disagree completely and I see the opposite.

THIS IS A GREAT film!

CAMARA design is EXCELLENT! it accompanies the story but it is playful on its own. IT HAS the perfect balance between realism and the "cartoonish" feel of it (DONE ON PURPOSE) because of the non-trustable NARRATOR, that keeps re-inventing herself! I have never seen such a creative and wonderful movie.

If the featured reviewer did not understand it, he should watch the movie with the director's comments about it, maybe it will shed some light!

Please ignore reviewer comments and WATCH IT!

reply

Agreed. I truly enjoyed this movie! SEE IT!

reply

This movie is about as interesting as watching a turd circle the bowl before finally being washed away.

reply

well, Jimmel, again, it is a matter of taste and it may be a matter of culture. If you read some Spanish literature (and I am not saying you have to) and have seen other movies from other countries, then you could understand a little bit more of it, or appreciate it, or see it under a different light. It is all a matter of background. The only comment, if you allow me to say so, is your attitude: you could be open to seeing more things in a movie than what you seem to look into (just the plain plot/story) and you could look into other aspects of it, or you can be close-minded, stay with what you know, and feel that the rest is organic waste! It is such a pity that it seems that what is not made with "cookie cutter" molds of what you know cinema to be - USA mainstream action films- goes completely under your radar... pity for you.

reply

It breaks my heart that the sort of person prone to posting insulting fake movie reviews likely spent his “fun money” on Bad Boys II last year rather than suicide implements. Let’s try a little experiment: let’s all just refuse to acknowledge his/her(?) existence from now on. With enough willpower, we can probably ignore them right out of the material plane. Next time one of their messages gets posted, I want you to say to yourself: “this poster no longer irritates me, because Jimmel does not exist in my world.” If you’re driving and you see Jimmel step into the crosswalk in front of you, hit the gas. He’s not really there.

reply

I loved this movie! Maybe Jimmel didn't like it because it's more of the type of film that a woman would relate to...

reply

Well, I don't agree with Jimmel, but the movie was rather slow. It sounded me a little pretentious, as well. But even if I would like it better with 20 minutes less, I still recomend it, spacially for people more sensitive than me ;)

reply

I loved this movie. What was there not to like? I'm confused?!
Tonight my dreams will be filled with the many vistas that were found in this gem of a movie.

New rule, all posters to this thread must be over 40! ;)

reply