The French aren't that dark and swarthy.


French people don't look like that. The French people in this movie look like Sicilians or Greeks.

reply

Corsica is in the middle of the Mediterranean, Mali is in North Africa, Guyana is in South America, Polynesia is in the centre of the Pacific,etc - you'd be hard pressed to say that the French have one distinct look everywhere. That's like saying Ghurkas aren't British or Hawaiians aren't American.




Ya Kirk-loving Spocksucker!

reply

Also, the great French naval bases were Brest in Brittany and Toulon in the Mediterranean; and the bulk of French shipping in general was based on the Breton and Mediterranean coasts. A ship sailing out of Toulon or any other port on the Mediterranean coast would likely have been largely manned by seamen from anywhere in the Mediterranean - not only Frenchmen but Spaniards, North Africans, Levantines. So on average they would have been darker than the mainstream population of France.

reply

That's like saying Ghurkas aren't British or Hawaiians aren't American.


That comparison doesn't make sense, the Ghurkas aren't British, all they are are Nepalese men who join a regiment of the British army, Hawaiians, on the other hand, are a people part of the state of Hawaii, which is a state of the US, those two aren't the same at all.

reply

The French are even darker today.

reply

That could be because of the foreign races moving into Europe. I imagine that there's been much race-mixing over the past generation or two on that continent.

reply

The French have quite a lot of dark-skinned genetics from their colonial period. Google "Alexandre Dumas Pere", the author of The Three Musketeers.

Generalizations are almost always wrong, because you will always find exceptions.



This signature really brings the room together, Does It Not?

reply

Actually they do. Most French people from the Central and Southern regions look like this. It's only the Northerners (who are naturalised Vikings anyway) look like Germanic peoples.

Hama cheez ba-Beer behtar meshawad!

reply

Southern France borders on Spain, and Southeastern France borders on Italy.

Need more indicators?

..Joe

reply

This story before sunblock, you know. Anyone who went to sea or just out into the sun got a hell of a tan.

reply

Some are.

reply