Thanks, this question helped me to define for me what it is about the original Asian ghost films that I prefer to the Hollywood remakes. The Hollywood versions have (arguably) higher production values and better actors, but more "pored over" scripts. It's like the American re-writers have had committee meetings about what the original movie was about and have discussed how to present this on a plate for the American - and I'm Australian but I count Australia as a suburb of the US for movie market purposes at least - audience.
The problem with this "worked out" script is that it's taken the viewer's decision making away. If you want to know what the Asian horror movie you just watched was about, just watch the Hollywood remake and it will beat it over your head with a cudgel. And you might gain something - you can call it understanding if you like - but you lose more I think. Because isn't a supernatural story inherently a mystery?
Dark Water is not even the worst example of this. Check out the difference between A Tale of Two Sisters and The Uninvited, for example. Is subtlety overrated? I don't think so.
I like to have questions in my head after watching a movie, and that's what you get with (some of these) the Asian movies. Not all of them - I didn't have any questions after Gin Gwai, for example, so I didn't have any curiosity about checking out The Eye.
reply
share