MovieChat Forums > Happily N'Ever After (2007) Discussion > Now HERE'S a good question--Shrek The Th...

Now HERE'S a good question--Shrek The Third, or Happily N'ever After?


Considering they're both partially about fairy tale villains taking over.

Justin Timberlake's part in "STT" gives "Happily" the edge for me.

reply

It's been a while since I seen Happily N'ever After, but after watching Shrek 3, I'am taking Happily N'Ever after

reply

Screw both of them, try watching Hoodwinked. Way better fun moments with the bad gfx of HNA :]

if you are reading this signature, it means that i had to have a bitch-session.

reply

I would definitely choose Happily N'Ever After. Shrek The Third was disappointing all round except for Justin Timberlake's efforts. At least it appeared that the makers of Happily N'Ever After had their heart in the project. Shrek The Third was just on autopilot.

reply

[deleted]

I absolutely loved Hoodwinked. It was a big surprise to me to find that I liked it. Def recommend it too.

reply

I loved Hoodwinked, too. And with Andy Dick!

Actually, I loved Happily N'Ever After more than I liked Shrek the Third (except for the warrior Princesses!) and in spite of SMG & FP, Jr. Shrek 1 & 2 were so good.

My favorite line from HNA is "I stole a baby" from Rumpelstiltskin.

reply

Happily N'Ever After, by far. There should not be a Shrek the Fourth.

J.T. dies.

reply

Neither were good.

reply

they were both terrible.

MY TOP 30 FILMS
http://landofcinema.forumcircle.com/viewtopic.php?t=1073

reply

Hoodwinked was better than this... but Shrek has the edge DESPITE Justin T...

Dwacon
http://blog.dwacon.com/

reply

You guys are insane, They both obviously sucked, but at least Shrek the Third had some actual funny jokes in there.
Happily N'Ever After was horrid.
Shrek the Third is definitely my vote

reply

Happily N'ever after in my opinion was better. None were good though!

reply

Both were terrible and highly disappointing. SHREK THE 3RD had a few moments though (too bad they were all revealed in the trailer/behind-the-scenes). HAPPILY NEVER AFTER didn't make me laugh even once. Which is rare for an animated feature film for me. I'd have to go with the former.

HOODWINKED! was great. Waaaay better than the two other movies combined!

reply

Hoodwinked was baddddd. Ok not the worst Ive seen but for animated its 1 of the lowest.

Do not believe this jibberish.

Shrek the Third is better than the other choices but if you really want to go into animated fairie tales, go with the Shrek series, namely Shrek 2.

reply

Hoodwinked was baddddd. Ok not the worst Ive seen but for animated its 1 of the lowest.

Do not believe this jibberish.

Shrek the Third is better than the other choices but if you really want to go into animated fairie tales, go with the Shrek series, namely Shrek 2.

reply

I can't believe you could give Hoodwinked a 1! The great musicals, the witty dialogue, unconventional twists.... that was one of the best animated films ever made! When I think of good cartoons I think of hoodwinked and the lion king.

reply

Happily N'ever After!

reply