amazing film


not only is andy goldsworthy a genius, this film showcasing his talents is a work of art in its own right. this movie is awesome. good job to all involved.

reply

build a stone wall around some trees -- oooh.

throw some snow in the air -- wow.

grind up some red rock and have it paint a river -- amazing.


please...this movie was a piece of pretentious crap.

reply

explain how it is and i will explain how it is not.

reply

[deleted]

This film was disappointing, in that it elevates rather simplistic methods into high art. There is nothing wondrous about Goldsworthy's method, it's just chance operations combined with decent photography. Not filmworthy, IMO.

I am big. It's the pictures that got small....

reply

We must have watched different films. Nothing suggests that his work is being elevated to any abstract idea like high art. Every piece he has made and recorded is about seeing it as it is, as he intends, and take it or leave it. You are reading into it a conceit that just isn't there.

And method has nothing to do with it. His work is all about process and if those two words mean the same to you.. well, I guess that explains your response.

reply

It was also incredibly boring

reply

[deleted]

I've now seen this movie three times and it continues to impress. Tonight we showed this to a group of High School age art students, and I would recommend it for students and artists of any age. The documentary shows the utmost respect for the artist and his work. Much of the film has no dialogue and the simple shots carefully and subtley reveal and artists work. What I really like about Goldsworthy is that the work is so satisfying on so many levels. The sculptures (for lack of a better term) are striking and beautiful. There is a nice conceptual side to his work (most sculptures remain in their natural environment to fall, crumble or float away.) Additionally the work is not the photographs/film of the sculptures; the work is what is there in nature, it can't be placed in the gallery. We only see the document, not the actual piece. Goldsworthy is clever and he uses natural materials in unique ways that are very unexpected and surprising. For much of the movie you are wondering "How'd he do that?" Finally it is the beauty and mystery of these works that stays with the viewer. An excellent documentary that shows more than it tells about its subject.

reply

"There is a nice conceptual side to his work (most sculptures remain in their natural environment to fall, crumble or float away.) "

It reminds me of the Tibetan sand paintings that are made with meticulous care only to be changed back into bags of sand.

reply

the word pretentious is a word morons use to basically say "Duh...I don't get it."

reply

I'm really impressed with this film and its subject. While so many contemporary artists are caught up in the gallery game, Goldsworthy went his own way to great success. His work is both intensely personal and monumental. This is one of the most enjoyable art documentaries I've seen.

reply

Though at times my husband and I mocked Goldsworthy for his hyperbole as the high priest of art (who needs God), the filmmakers do him honor in filming him and his scuptural, conceptual art which show that time is fleeting... What is this world we live in, if even the rocks and granite walls are ever moving and changing? What is the artist saying about us and our fleeting lives?



reply

'the word pretentious is a word morons use to basically say "Duh...I don't get it."'

Indeed.

Loved the movie! We happened on it by chance & watched the whole thing. Very well done. I guess some people were looking for a documentary about erosion (ha! Seriously, read some other reviews - too freakin' funny how daft some people are) or, um, I don't know, boobies and car chases?

All in all, a great movie, and I can't wait to own it.

reply