MovieChat Forums > American Crime (2004) Discussion > I actually liked it a lot

I actually liked it a lot


Of course, not the best film ever, but there were a lot of unique aspects that were nice to see.

It was very original in its formatting. I'm sure there are other movies like it out there, but I had never seen one that began by centering around a crime show investigation. But whoever seemed to investigate became the next potential victim.

I also liked a lot of the subtle techniques used. How it would transition into a different scene by actually going "into" the TV. Or the TVs in random places that would flicker names of segments, and the same TVs were located towards the end on the side of the road, but they were off or broken. Finally, I know the idea that the "killer is still out there" has been done before, but it's certainly not the mainstream way to go. Most movies are so straightforward: killer kills, killer exposed, killer caught-the world is happy again (unless it's a movie about supernatural or superpowered killers, in which case rules are thrown out the window whenever). But this movie took the chance of having a realistic ending: one where not everyone lives happily ever after. Sometimes the bad guys do win, and nobody ever knows who they are.

Now, a lot of gripes have been made about that character of Albert. I was aggravated by him too. However, I think this was partly the purpose of his character. The over-the-top accent, the constant twitching, and the all-in-all fakeness of his character. At first, they may seem like mistakes or something close. However, the character is MEANT to be fake. He's also meant to be a little crazy since he has such a severe problem with anger. As a result, almost everything he does is meant to be fake. Since the real show wouldn't accept him, he made up a world in his mind that would.

I think one of the biggest things I liked about this movie besides the formatting was the ending. It was an ending that left tons of possibilities and no definite solution. However, I've watched movies like that where I was soooo pissed because of how they teased you about the fact that you'd never know. But for some reason, I wasn't angry that I didn't know. The bad guy won. It happens in real life. In this case, a part of winning was concealing his identity, even to the audience.

The movie, of course, leaves a lot open for interpretation. The only two bodies never recovered were Jesse's and Rob's, so it leaves you wondering "why." Where one of the two the killers? But you know Rob wasn't since he got slammed on the back of the head and you saw him being followed. So what, then, happened to his body? Maybe it was just never found, and that's just what happens sometimes in real life.

A main gripe I may have about the movie, if any, would be how stupid and yet arrogant all of the police and detectives were portrayed in the movie. Albert was obviously freaked out in the tape at the end of the movie, but the detectives paid no mind. Hell, it didn't even make sense why he would confess on tape then try to act like he was forced to do it if he really did do it. But, once again, I suppose people in real life really are like that sometimes: just trying to close a case, they don't look at all the possibilities.

So I know I don't hold the popular opinion here, but I just thought I'd share my thoughts. When I watch a movie, I try to let it encompass me. When that happens, I realize that some of the things that may appear to be mistakes or bad acting on the surface may have, in actuality, been on purpose. Plus, worst-comes-to-worst, I can take at least something out of a movie, no matter how bad people may think it was.

All of this being said, that's my opinion: I really did enjoy this movie quite a bit.

reply

dragon_flame is not alone. i agree w/ everything he/she said. i enjoyed it too & recommend it as at least being worth a rental price.

reply

I definitely agree with Dragon-Flame with most of what was said. I do wish I would have known who the killer was, but it does leave it open for a sequal. I caught it on cable one day last week and when it ended I was aggravated because I wanted to know who the killer was. But when I saw that it was on again yesterday, I was drawn to watch it. If they can get people to watch a movie more than once, then the job was done right, ya know? Albert Bodine was an annoyance, but as Dragon-Flame states, he was supposed to be over-the-top. I didn't realize how much I enjoyed this movie until I watched it again. Just want to know who did it!!!!!!!!

reply

I liked the satirical (SP?) aspect of the movie also. I also noticed that most of the main characters are flawed, with the possible exception of Jessie. There really isn't a typical hero type to root for, although I didn't want any of them actually killed. Except, possibly, the narrow minded sheriff!

reply

I liked it too - Loved Annabella in Sopranos so I figured it was worth a watch - seemed a little unique - not alot of gore which I also liked - builing up to each one having a possibility of being the killer - I wouldn't recommend it to anyone but it was a good film for a rainy day stuck inside the house

reply

me 7?

i found it highly entertaining and unique. and i LOVED Elwes' character!
he did a terrific job with a truly repugnant role.

but apparantly, no one is on the fence about this funky little film; love it or hate it.

A child of five would understand this, send someone to fetch a child of five.
GROUCHO MARX

reply

picked this up at the bargain bin. didnt expect anything spectacular. it was corny but was fun to watch if you dont take it seriously.

reply

I came across this at Blockbuster while looking for another movie...saw Kip Pardue, who I've remembered since seeing him in Remember the Titans, and of course Anabella from Hand That Rocks the Cradle. I too agree that the movie was not so bad; it was entertaining to me.

The ending and the entering of the house scene at the end got me all confused, but has anyone considered that maybe Jessie (Rachel) and Rob (Kip) might have orchestrated all of this since they did say at the end that their bodies weren't found? I wonder...
One more thing, what was it that makeup did to Cary Elwes that made him look so different? It definitely fit the weirdness of the character but I just can't put my finger on what made him look less handsome than I've seen him in other movies.

reply

Make-up -- I noticed red marks on his cheeks, and he was always sweaty... I also think they did soemthing to his nose.

reply

Very flawed, but I liked it too :) The characters were endearing & it didn't take itself too seriously, so I went along with it -- loved Cary Elwes as Albert (cannot believe all the hate!) & Annabella Sciorra was, as usual, perfect. I must admit, the ending irked me a little, only because it didn't *explicitly* confirm my suspicion that it was Jesse (RLC's wig -- ughhh!)... but I suppose the fact that the profile drawn for Albert was a perfect fit for Jesse/(& Rob ?) & her undiscovered body were enough ---- but the MO is more typical of a male offender, isn't it?

Oh well. It was good, that is all!

reply