MovieChat Forums > Home on the Range (2004) Discussion > I just saw it! And it's GREAT!!

I just saw it! And it's GREAT!!


Damn.

That was a good movie.

I'm just sad it was the last one.

It's similar to "The Emperor's New Groove" in that it's more of a "cartoon" than an "animated feature" (what's the difference, you ask? Aniamted features--like Snow White, Pinocchio, and Brother Bear--are typically dramatic films set in a quasi-realistic fantasy world, while cartoons are primarily comedies and feature all the viloence, sight gags, and other such elements we associate with slapstick humor).

But "Home on the Range" is funny. Hella funny. It kept me laughing all the way throughout.

It's also fast-paced. Hella fast-paced. And violent (cartoonily violent. Particularly its "blink-and-you'll-miss-something" climax, which I may need to go back to see again because I was laughing so hard that I may have missed parts of it. Disney most definitely (and literally) went out on a BANG.

But it's highly recommended. I'd say it's just a notch below "The Emperor's New Groove" and "Lilo & Stitch," making it better than "Brother Bear," "Atlantis," and that godawful travesty known as "Treasure Planet."

The animation is very well done, with the angular character designs that work surprisingly well when being turned in three dimensions (but hey, that's Disney for you!). The animation is done a lot more in the style of a Warner Brothers cartoon than a Disney picture, in as far as the extreme fast motion, the cartoony movements of the animals (Buck the horse has fantasies of being a Western kung-fu hero--the picture briefly segues into a CinemaScope sequence depicting one of his fantasies)

All the voice work is pretty well done (Roseanne doesn't grate...thank GOD!), with the stand-outs being Cuba Gooding, Jr. as Buck (He did a good job on TOP of a good job...he should voice act more often!), Steve Buschemi (who isn't given terribly too much screen time, but he takes what he's given to town and back), and a hilarious-on-top-of-hilarious cameo voice appearance by PATRICK-freaking-WARBURTON (Kronk from "The Emperor's New Groove")!! Oh MAN; I was on the floor when I heard his voice

For those of you who miss singing DIsney characters, you get one last song in this film, and it is the absolute highlight of the picture...and one of the absolute highlights of Disney animation in general..and I can't even tell you what it is without spoiling a major plot point for you. But suffice it to say that I was so impressed that my jaw was moping the floor.

Negatives? Well...there's a few gratuitous "Deep Canvas" 3D background shots in this film...I guess today's audiences have such a [thing] for 3D that they absolutely REQUIRE 3D camera moves in a film that really doesn't need any. They ARE well-done, nonetheless.

*SIDENOTE*: I went to a showing with lots of old people and tiny babies with their parents...and only me and the parents seemed to be having a good time (same problem with "The Emperor's New Groove"). Sure you got a kid laugh every now and then, but the kids got a bigger response out of the trailer for "The Spongebob Squarepants Movie" that ran before the film started than they did for the film itself. Their parents had a better time than they did. Today's kids ain't got much taste, do they? (j/k) :)

I stayed during the end credits and read them all (as I always do for any film), and I almost began to cry as I was reading some of the names of folks who'd been working on Disney films for decades and decades before that...like Shawn Keller, who animated Lucky Jack the peg-legged jackrabbit (someone cut off his lucky rabbit's foot) and Bruce W. Smith (the director of "Bebe's Kids" and the creator of "The Proud Family"--and yes, he's a Negro) who was lead animator on Pearl the farm lady. And ink-and-painter Carmen Sanderson, who had been working for Disney so long that she was an ink-and-painter on Pinocchio back in 1940.

The grand majority of them folks are out of a job.

But this is a very, VERY nice film and it'll stand as a monument to a great American art form and great American entertainment.

And I will be back to see it again.

reply

"All the voice work is pretty well done (Roseanne doesn't grate...thank GOD!), with the stand-outs being Cuba Gooding, Jr. as Buck (He did a good job on TOP of a good job...he should voice act more often!), Steve Buschemi (who isn't given terribly too much screen time, but he takes what he's given to town and back), "
<<That is awesome! I've got my tickets for tonight...and I cannot wait to hear the voice of Rosanne (this is a good thing, so you say!!) come out of a fat cow!! I watched the trailer again on the website - and I am getting psyched...

reply

stop watching that trailer...or actually keep watching it...so you'll be surprised how good the actual movie is...

reply

This was a decent movie.

And when it comes out on DVD, I will buy it. But Ill be sure to rank it with my other "B" Disney movies like Aristocats and Rescuers. Simply put, the commitment to character and story development was lacking.

I also checked out some of the reviews as well and I can understand the critics reasoning for giving it a "B" while some reviews even went as low as a "C".
src: http://metromix.chicagotribune.com/movies/mmx-040402-movies-review-mw-homeontherange,0,723631.story?coll=mmx-movies_top_heds
http://www.boston.com/movies/display?display=movie&id=4605

I thought the idea of cows as the main characters was sort of dull, but the plot moves along and by the end, I was satisfied, but not impacted.

Still, Disney's touch of quality is still evident. Give kudos to Disney for doing a FANTASTIC job in casting the voices. I am personally not a huge fan of Rosanne and her style of humor, but she fits the role of Maggie the Cow like a glove. (The camera zooms in on her back side and Maggie's response is, "Yeah, theyre real!) I have to mention that Cuba Gooding's voice of Buck was as perfect of a fit as Robin Williams is to voicing the Genie. Gooding has a sort of "weasing" laugh that is just right for an equine. (haha)

The stylized look that Disney used to do the characters wasnt too harsh. But youre right, the humans were softer in shape (why?). What pulled me in were the backgrounds and environments. I was drawn in by the great use of color, and how well Disney artists captured "the Ol West" essence. While some scenes looked like a setting for the Road Runner and Wily Coyote, all scenes had a shimmering glow (Ranch, farm, desert, etc.).

I totally agree that Disney needs to loosen its grip on the animation staff and let creativity flow. SaveDisney.com explains it well in some of their articles when they described how the executive MBAs stifle the creative process by only looking at productivity. Unless this changes, Pixar will continue to be the reigning storyteller.

"I can never stand still. I must explore and experiment. I am never satisfied with my work. I resent the limitations of my own imagination." - Walt E. Disney

reply

I just saw this movie too, it was cool, and ( for all those people who keep saying how horrible it is) its for KIDS!!!! I took my 6 year old little sis who liked it well enough its no classic like Little Mermaid but then after all these years they have to run out of ideas sometime!!!!!!!!!!

reply

It's not just for kids. In fact, I noted that most of the kids in my showing didn't get a lot of the jokes. *I* enjoyed it more than they did.

If you like cartoons (of the wacky, violent, hilarious Warner Bros. variety), then this is the movie for you...

reply

What? Have I been asleep? Are you telling me that this is the last animated film from Disney?

Kissmystarfishpucker

reply

I thought it was a great movie-and not only fun for the kids but the parents too!

reply

I think it's a good movie ! a 10/10...I see why the negativity. The animation and backgrounds are pretty, it has a retro appeal to it like some of the other Disney Classics...from the 1950s that is. The film also has an excellent soundtrack with some of today's best Country artists like : k.d Lang,Bonnie Rait and Tim McGraw.
--
*nya* *purr*

reply

Oh I didn't think there was any negativity.

Christina Barrett

reply

I really enjoyed it, too!

~The Unofficial Ricardo Antonio Chavira Fanclub~
http://tinyurl.com/9mb6hf

reply

I just finished watching it,it was very adorable,funny and cute,nice story too,I really don't understand the bad critics! I also love it is traditionally animated,reminds me to my childhood. 10/10

reply