MovieChat Forums > How's Your News? Discussion > what's the point of this doc?

what's the point of this doc?


Arthur Bradford, what's the point? How am I supposed to feel about you leaving a disabled person by a New York subway inaudibly asking for help? That New Yorkers are rude? How ground-breaking. Sending inaudible people that can't help themselves to interview random people on the street? I think you think you're funny. Your documentary makes as much sense as Bobby's questions in the film. Good Luck. You should just stay behind the camera and continue getting coffee for the rest of the crew.

reply

What's the point? This is the most uplifting life affirming movie I have ever seen! You seem to have a very low opinion of people with different abilities that you/disabilites. Too bad. Bobby's question's were incredible, by the way, but of course you can't be bothered with people who "can't help themselves" doing beautiful things, meeting amazing people, and have the best time of their lives. What is your problem dude? Are you a businessman or something? What did you want the point to be?

reply

No, DUDE, I'm not insensitive. My only uncle has downs and we hang out all the time. Bobby's questions were incredibly inaudible. Sure, they had a good time doing what they did. But I could see people watching this in a whole different way. I just think the parts with Bobby make the people who approcach him and the people watching the movie uncomfortable. what was the point of that? Could YOU explain that point to me, DUDE? And no, I'm not a businessman and what the hell would that have to do with anything, anyway? Are you a Surfer or something, DUDE?

reply

I agree. Most parts with merely cringe-worthy, and I could detect no meaning or message to the film. Was it exploitation? Was it brave? Probably not either. Mostly pointless, like watching someone's home movie.

reply

Please see my reply to Supermanic.

reply

Bobby, Ronnie, Susan, Sean, and Larry were just trying to interact with people. And they did. You can listen to the film's creators talk about the movie here:

http://www.thisamericanlife.com/Radio_Episode.aspx?sched=1198

Supermanic, if your opinion is well-founded, find some professionals that work with mentally and physically disabled people. Let them watch "How's Your News" on their own, so they can form their own opinions. Then see how many of them share your opinion.

In point of fact, you'll be hard-pressed to do so. I work with a broad range of mentally and physically disabled people. I find this movie uplifting, as do all of my colleagues.

reply

I'm going to completely endorse what nocat says here.

I just watched this film and it's simply fantastic. Watching it I felt overwhelming respect for everybody involved on both sides of the camera. I don't think I've ever seen another film or TV program about people with physical or intellectual disabilities in which the audience goes beyond sympathy or even respect, but relates to them as ...people. Individuals, with their own personalities. Whose lives have meaning beyond their disability (or as some might prefer, 'different ability'). I think this is because the cast were responsible for so much of the creative input. It was clearly a shared project between everybody involved; an equal enterprise between the able bodied crew and the cast themselves.

I was utterly impressed by the wit, character and humour on show - their singing, dancing, and all their other great talents just blew me away! But what I liked best was that I could completely relate to them, as I do to my friends or just other people I like on the TV.

Because I wasn't being asked to focus on their disability the whole time. I was being invited to share a joke or an experience with them... They did such a wonderful job of inviting the audience into the movie, I felt like I was on the bus too. All of them did their respective jobs amazingly well.

They're adults, and they're making their own choices. If you're uncomfortable during the New York scenes, that's okay - but you are the one who's got a problem with it, not Larry. Larry's just a guy who's making a film with his friends, and has decided to do a bit in NY where he tries to interview people on the street. When people stopped and talked, that was cool. When they didn't, Larry was cool with that too - because he's a grown up, and he was able to show you a little of what his life is like.

It was simple, effective film making from people with a lot of talent who are only usually allowed to show their disabilities.

I dropped by IMDB out of curiosity to see what was being said, and I have to say - I never could have foreseen that there would be this kind of negativity and a middling score. I'd hate anybody to read this stuff and decide not to watch it. This is a first class film from a really cool bunch of people.

I wish I had a more eloquent vocabulary and could avoid using that word 'disability' all the time. This film is a perfect example of the reason why. I saw some people with twisted legs or bad sight, and others who had a hard time understanding certain things. And I could see how that made some aspects of their lives a pain (most of all, getting people to actually listen to them). But the thing I could see more clearly than any of that was their talents and abilities. They were all more than able people.

Great film.

reply

This was one of the worst movies I have seen in a long time. Lindsay-mankf, I don't disagree that this movie can be uplifting. Obviously many people do find it to be so.

My problem I don't even consider this a movie. There IS no point. I was trying to explain this movie to a friend of mine this morning and this is as far as I could get. "A group of mentally disable/handicapped people get on a bus to go across a country and interview people. About what I don't know...They ask people their names, what their dreams are, to sing songs with them, what church they go to, and more arbitrary questions."

I cannot believe this "movie" apparently did so well at film festivals. To me this "movie" is completely exploitative. If you were to make the same movie with a group of people without disabilitis no one would care besides maybe friends and family.


The most ridiculous scene was when the filmmaker or producer or whoever that was wheeled the handicapped man in the wheel chair into the busy New York street. He was literally just sitting and wiggling there for a good two minutes. And then a man tries to speak with him. WHat on earth is the point of this?!

reply


I hate the the boards are going away, because where the **** else am I going to talk to *anyone* about this doc? Anyway, I sort of agree with you in that parts were very uncomfortable to watch. The scene where the guy was wheeled into the crowd and left there stuck with me, and I might not have watched much beyond that point (that's why I haven't rated the movie). I had nothing against anyone in he movie, but some scenes seemed sort of insensitive, and kind of made me cringe, like you said.

But given that some experienced people in the field of education and outreach have said that this is a motivating doc, that makes me want to give it anger try. There are some docs that I've tuned off, only to finish later, after which I was surprised I ever didn't like it. :P

reply

NoCat, you think I'm going to talk to professionals about this? Wow. Why would I speak to professionals to see if they share my opinion? I don't care if they do or not. All I'm saying is if a turd could take a *beep* this movie would come out.

reply