The Pressure Suits


I thought it odd that someone thought to bring pressure suits along on a trip through solid rock and metal. How would they know they would have any reason to step outside that ship.


reply

Why do astronauts wear suits even when they're not scheduled for space walks? Because you just never know when an emergency could arise.

Example of senility.http://img638.imageshack.us/img638/2779/paintx.png

reply

I understand regarding space. But solid rock?

reply

It's not just solid rock or the need to leave the vessel. The ship could depressurize. They could suffer a toxic leak inside the ship. Their temp. control system could fail and require them to suit up to fix it. It's the same for astronauts.

Example of senility.http://img638.imageshack.us/img638/2779/paintx.png

reply

The pressure in deep earth is enough to squich a human like a tube of mayoneese
according to scientists. But their suits didn't look like the kind of suits that
could even hold up to that kind of pressures.

reply

Space is easy, it's empty

reply

To be fair, the further they go, the more molten the rock and metal.

My problem with the EVA scene and suits is two-fold.

Firstly, under the pressures described, pretty sure they would hardly be able to move, but they were functioning as though under normal atmospheric conditions.

And what the hell were the big transparent faceplates supposedly made from? Sure wasn't the invulnerable stuff. At very least, make them just big enough to barely look out from, instead of the silly Hollywood need to display the actors' faces. Hell, for that matter, surprised they didn't make them giant glass bubbles to show their hairstyles too...

But more in keeping with the technology of the movie, the suits should've been solid Unobtainium (lol) fitted with the same navigational tech for the ship.

Mostly though, those giant, thin, transparent faceplates would've been exceptionally vulnerable to the heat (much less pressure), and their heads would soon overheat, which might've been an interesting limitation to use in the story, as long as they were embracing the ridiculous.

"I like to watch" Chauncey Gardiner, 'Being There'

reply

If you think that is bad the latest Star Trek movie has Spock inside an active volcano right near the lava

reply

If you think that is bad the latest Star Trek movie has Spock inside an active volcano right near the lava
Exactly.

reply

If you think that is bad the latest Star Trek movie has Spock inside an active volcano right near the lava


Yea but was the pressure the same in the active volcano as a couple hundred miles down into the earth core? is what I think this debate is about :/ if you want to talk about the scientific inaccuracy of the temperature that these suits can withstand I'm sure there's another thread covering this topic for you to put your amazing statement 😃

" No, we are not relations, sir"

reply

Firstly, under the pressures described, pretty sure they would hardly be able to move, but they were functioning as though under normal atmospheric conditions.

They were in a geode. So, it wouldn't be any different than being in their ship. The enormous pressure is being exerted on the outside of the geode, protecting what's inside. Just as a submarine protects its inhabitants while diving deep in the ocean. Why they said "I'm sure glad the suits can take the pressure" is beyond me. They should have said "I'm sure glad the suits can take the heat".


Example of senility.http://img638.imageshack.us/img638/2779/paintx.png

reply

and at 1 million pounds PSI-it would have been a BREEZE to swim though!

reply

And what the hell were the big transparent faceplates supposedly made from? Sure wasn't the invulnerable stuff. At very least, make them just big enough to barely look out from, instead of the silly Hollywood need to display the actors' faces

The spacesuit in the film "Sunshine" has to be one of the best. The faceplate was just a letterbox opening, also the fact that it had a golden-reflective surface made it even more striking

reply

A shard falls from the "ceiling" of the giant geode, slices through the top of his helmet and into his head. Shouldn't he have been crushed by all the pressure entering his helmet?

reply

A shard falls from the "ceiling" of the giant geode, slices through the top of his helmet and into his head. Shouldn't he have been crushed by all the pressure entering his helmet?


Not to mention his head should be sliced open like a watermelon with that too.

reply

Exactly. And why did they bring an entire crew of engineers and scientists who designed the ship. All they needed was bringing 1 pilot and maybe, just maybe one more navigator/technician. That's it.

reply

I suppose you are correct. That is, perhaps # 793 of the vast list of utterly insane things that make up this movie. The entire film is a structure made up of individual points of insanity, orbiting a nucleus of stupidity and forming a sort of ATOM of Awfulness.
Not,that I don't like it...

reply