MovieChat Forums > 2009 loseuteu maemorijeu (2002) Discussion > One thing I don't get - isn't their time...

One thing I don't get - isn't their timeline a 'better' one?


Speaking as a Brit with absolutely no knowledge of Korean history, is it me, or wouldn't the corrupted timeline represent a better world for more people?

Corrupted timeline: no atom bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. No Korean civil war, no North Korea. Japan on winning side in WW2, prosperous throughout the 20th Century (and as part of a unified Japan, this prosperity would include Korea).

Seems to me that the average member of the public in both Koreas and Japan would be much better off in "their" timeline. Why on earth try to "correct" it back to ours?

I realise it was supposed to be a flag-waving Korean patriotism piece, but apart from Korean independence, I can't help but thinking the wrong side won in this film!

Enjoyed it nonetheless :)

reply

[deleted]

How about a fact that Koreans of the new timeline lived pretty much under dictatorship?
Nowadays too South Korea and Japan are pretty much equal economically... Though, of course, if we take into account North Korea it's different.
In the other timeline Berlin was bombed using nuclear weapons......

It looked ok on the first glance but when you looked deeper you saw that Japanese occupied all the best jobs and Koreans were second class citizens (except some, like the main hero)

And no, I'm not a Korean...

reply

No. The corrupted timeline is NOT a BETTER timeline.

As a Brit, it might be more understandable film where instead of Japan, it was Nazi Germany. And all the Aryans and collaborators had prosperous lives and was a "better world". But it would be a false paradise build upon the suffering of subjugation of those excluded from the ruling power.

Although there was no bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, there was instead the atom bombing of Berlin.

Also, if you noticed, it is mentioned that most of the people in prison are Koreans. And the small Koreatowns that still exists are considered slums and shady places. And from the continual mention of the main character's Korean heritage, despite all his contributions to the Japanese government and his work, he is still considered an outsider, distrusted, and not fully accepted.

In other words, this corrupted timeline is "better" and "prosperous" for only or mostly Japanese people. Most of the people subjugated by Japan then, (most of Asia) would have been considered second class citizens, with limited autonomy or freedoms.

And if you have EVER researched ANYTHING about Japanese Imperialism, then you would DEFINITELY know that they are not the good guys.

reply

Imperialists are never the good guys. That says nothing about the Japanese. I'm from the US and we were the last imperialists. Before us it was the British, then the French, Dutch, Portuguese, etc. in various orders.

I know little of Southeast Asian history but I'm curious if from your perspective, you might feel that one unspoken goal of the time alteration in the movie might have been to return the nuclear bombs to Japan. I wonder if a desire for retribution was as strong as the desire to not live under foreign rule. I don't have an interest one way or the other but I am curious.

reply