I own it and watch it every year as part of my Christmas marathon, but it's one of the weaker links in my dozens of tapes. Actually, it just aired as part of ABC Family's 25 Days of Christmas, so plenty of people have heard of it by now. One of my biggest problems with it is the very premise that after the original, Rudolph is still pained by wanting a normal nose and to be just like everyone else. Perhaps he still has moments of feeling that, but no WAY is he still saddled with it as a major emotional conflict. They just wanted him to have a personal problem to work through, and couldn't find another.
The bizarre lack of good ol' Sam the Snowman, and the fact that Rudolph and Clarice should be adults instead of their cute little younger selves again (which I'm sure they felt they had to use in order to sell this), do not help matters. The animation is very poor, and while I rather do like Hermey, Queen Camilla, the Toy Taker, and most of the other new or returning characters & songs in this, it's not worthy of more than 6 or a generous 7/10.
reply
share