MovieChat Forums > Metoroporisu (2002) Discussion > Japanese or English soundtrack?

Japanese or English soundtrack?


I will watch this (masterpiece?) very shortly. For the best first impression, which version is preferable?

reply

DEFINATELY ENGLISH AUDIO. It keeps your eyes on the art rather than the subtitles. Then listen to the Japanese to get the overall Metropolis experience.

reply

About to compare the two myself. Watched it in Japanese the first time through, (which is what I tend to do,) and I thought it was rather good that way, but have yet to compare.

reply

I've only seen the english version, but I thought it was one of the best dubs I've ever heard...

reply

After watching both version, I have to say that the english dub is far superior. The japanese seiyu didn't sound like they were puting any emotion into their acting.

reply

The Japanese is better. The English dub is not the English translation (you notice there are two subtitle tracks for English one being for the English dub) Trust me, it is very easy to lose things in the translation so the less it is removed from the original source material the better. For one thing, there are several phrases that are untranslatable and while that is not beneficial to someone not knowing Japanese, the English inserted would ruin all of it.

reply

Always go for English dub even if it's worse in quality (unless you know Japanese, you will never know) in comparison.

Besides, watching with language you understand means you can concentrate on action and art on-screen instead of reading subs like a tard. Movie has less impact that way. Even with *beep* VA you can appreciate everything on screen at the same time.

reply

Besides, watching with language you understand means you can concentrate on action and art on-screen instead of reading subs like a tard.


You must read slow. I've never had an issue reading and taking in the art.

Can't stop the signal.

reply

Are you a speed reader now?

reply

Now? Silly boy. Always.

Can't stop the signal.

reply

How dare you assume my pronouns. Bad troll. Bad.

reply

Boy is not a pronoun, sweetie.

Can't stop the signal.

reply

Bad troll. Bad.

reply

Bad English.

reply

2/10 troll

reply

At least I know grammar.

reply

Do you want to know how you can tell someone doesn't have a legitimate rebuttal for someone?

They get worked up over someone's grammar.

reply

Sweetie, the whole point of your post was your bad grammar. If you don't want to look stupid, don't be stupid.

Can't stop the signal.

reply

You have no point. See? You just admitted it.

reply

Shh. It's obvious you lack a basic elementary school education.

reply

You must read slow. I've never had an issue reading and taking in the art.


I have no intentions of becoming the kind of twat who spends time reading while watching a movie. I read books for that purpose.

But keep at it.

Can't stop the derp.

reply

Can't do more than one thing at a time, huh? Keep practicing. You'll get the hang of it.

reply