STRANGE FILM


Who is supposed to watch this film? Is it:
a) for kids?
b) for adults?

a) i think it's not for kids: too many politics and violence (state assault, assassination of president and "mengele doc", this fascist shooting everybody, main character - cute little girl - becomes Terminatrix and destroys everything), people treat those sympathetic robots like sh*t, and not very happy ending

b) i don't think it's for adults - no erotics at all, the plot is a little bit childish and not very strict, main characters are kids, and it's animated.

So im confused. It gained 7.3 in 10 degree scale from IMDB users. I liked it too, even if i don't know what is so f... great in this movie.

reply

Pretty sure this movie is geared towards adults. Thematically it seems a little complex for children. Also… In Japan they don’t have the stigma of animation being for children only. That’s more of a North American idea. I think your right about the children as the main characters but they are not completely central to story. For the absence of erotics, I’d say that not all films intended for adults have this, and as for the childish plot, I don’t think a plot can be described as childish. Are you sure you know what the word means?

reply

"I don’t think a plot can be described as childish" - why not? Compare plot of this film with "Blade Runner" - another adult futuristic film about artificial intelligence - see difference? I mean things like solar weapon making stains on sun - it would be good in comic book for kids; those melodramatic dialogues between Rock & Duke ("I told you don't call me FATHER!"); the boy disapears in burning factory and his uncle don't call the police for help to find him cause it would be too easy etc. Maybe i'm just malicious, but i like to mess about details.
But now i think "melodramatic" would be better word here than "childish".

Anyway it's quite good film.

reply

This film is much to complex for small kids. I am 16 and have just finished watching it. The age of the characters don't matter in any film it only depends on the plot and theme. The theme in this film is somewhat political, yet it also focuses on the relationship between Tima and Ken-Ichie along with the relationship between Tima and her actual being. Most of the scenes in this film are absolutely beautiful, especially the scene where Tima stands on the roof in a patch of light and the dove perches on her shoulder. Some people watching her comment that "she looks like an angel". Find this ironic and strange? Tima becomes an object for destruction. Realize also how half of her face is ripped off to show robotic parts before she falls. This is some complex stuff for people who actually understand it...so that definitely rules out kids. This is not just another children's animated film...this is not The Lion King, or Aladdin. This has a message that needs to be understood.


"May we have permission to search your pie?"-Captain Stottlemeyer

reply

[deleted]

I showed this film to my mom, and she liked it. Maybe the movie is for some adults because films like this dont always impress them, except for some, but maybe this film is more for kid older than 7 or 8 I suppose. True, the plot is a bit complex but I understood it. I guess I should anyway, Im 13 years old.

reply

I totally agree with Marllow words,specially about the ''In Japan they don’t have the stigma of animation being for children only.''

I am an adult and I like to see animations and cartoons.

reply

i just find it funny that one of the OP's criteria for being an adult oriented animation film is "erotics". for me to enjoy a film as an adult, there must be some nudity or sex - especially if its an anime.

reply

This is a common misconception in the United States, I think mainly caused by Walt Disney - the idea that animated films are made for children. It's this idea that keeps so many movie watchers in this country from giving films like this a valid chance, and prompts them/us to ask this question.

But to answer, it is made for an adult audience. I seriously doubt American, Japanese, or whatever nationality of parents are letting their 6-year olds watch stuff like this.

reply

i agree - animation can still be a serious genre but i don't think the way the characters were created (looking like astro boy) was the right idea. movies like GITS have more realistic representations for more serious subject matter, but this looked and reminded me of kid's animation with heavy dialogue

what was with some of their noses lol?

like at least twice the size of their faces

reply

children have fun with everything, but my mother ( a latin history teacher ) start sleeping in 20 minutes. :(
music is boring.
plot is predictable.
animation is outstanding, but in europe we want substance not eye candy.

reply

i was probably like 7 years old when i saw this, confused me a lot. haha.

reply

In Tezuka's original manga, Duke Red was a criminal who took on several disguises and was only known by his oversized nose. Most of the characters retain the same look as they had in the original manga. I, for one, hate Tezuka's style because his art is very dated and influenced by Walt Disney, himself. This film is not aimed at any age group. I believe it is intended for the largest audience. Katsuhiro Otomo who wrote the script also created Akira, which is fairly niched within the 16-24 year old niche, specifically the junior high and high school boys when the original manga was serialized in Japan. Metropolis resembles Akira more than Tezuka's original manga, so I think Otomo was trying to get the same sort of messages across that he did with his manga and film that was not enjoyed by such a large audience. Metropolis, I believe, is easily accessible to young, old, male and female audiences. The reason the film looks the way it does and sounds the way it does is to create not only Tezuka's original look and feel (the manga came out around 1950) but also to capture the German futurism that helped inspire Tezuka (the female robot from Fritz Lang's Metropolis. Also, it is correct that Japan does not have the same connotation for animation that is in America. In fact, America is about the only country that views animation as childish. (Percipolus, Triplets of Bevelle) I don't know the reason, but it may have something to do with the fact that the majority of Japanese cinema today is characterized with cheesy overacting.

reply

So ... the only thing that makes a movie "adult" is erotics? Huh.

reply

Agree with that.

Also, many movies that have children as main characters are for adults. I recently watched another anime, Grave of the fireflies, which tells the story of a young boy and his little sister trying to survive alone in Japan during World War II. It´s a very wretched tale and the boy´s sister starves to death in the end. It´s definetely not a film for kids. The main characters illustrate the misery children suffer in war, and to convey that message they had to use children as main characters (besides it makes the film a whole lot more emotional). That´s what was done with this movie too, I believe. Kenichi and Tima represented innocence and because they are children it is even sadder to see what happens to them and how Tima is used by Duke Red.

reply

It's not terrible but it's by no means great either. It has a high score on imdb because the artist was the original guy that created astro boy decades ago - so there're a lot of biased fans voting.

To get a more reliable and credible guage on anime check the ratings over at www.anidb.net or www.animenewsnetwork.com

reply

[deleted]