MovieChat Forums > Ghost Ship (2002) Discussion > Is cable wire capable of slicing that ma...

Is cable wire capable of slicing that many people?


When the cable wire slashed through the dancing guests at the beginning of the movie, why was the captain the only one that had the cable wire going through his head while everyone else was cut midsection? Or was there other people cut through the head, only not shown in the movie?

Also, since its already been established in other topics that it is possible for cable wires to cut body parts, is it possible for a cable wire to cut multiple bodies at the same time like it did in the beginning of the movie?

Thanks.

reply

To me it felt like a stupid mistake that people were cut by the wire from so many different spots. It's really funny to watch how one person is cut from around the bellybutton and another from his mouth. So I think it was a mistake. I believe it's also mentioned as a goof here on IMDb.

For you second question I have no answer because I have no idea.


Sheppard: The clowns? We fight them too. Entire armies, spilling out of Volkswagens.

reply

Actually I read that the captain bent down to protect Katie, and thats how he got cut through the mouth and such.

reply

I just watched that scene. The captain never ducked down.

reply

No, but he was dancing with her in a crouched over stance - Like you do when you dance with a child at a wedding for example.

The cable cut people at different sections because people were doing different things and were different heights.

reply

OMG people, go and send a letter to myth busters and they can demonstrate it and see if it could possibly be done!

reply

Best response, ever!

Let's be friends!

reply

This is a discussion board. Do you run into footlocker and yell why sneakers are being sold there? Nutjob.

reply

Lol, Mythbusters did this movie eventually.

reply



Carlos Aneiro

About this opening Scene; the question should not be about how wire can cut...the question should be: Why give the Captain's Ball in the Fo'c'sle???
A merchantman's forecastle is where there is machinery, docking gear, cargo hatches, & in general stuff normal passengers would not be around with, because of the riskiness involved in their being there, & because forecastles, because of the machinery, are usually filthy & greasy, not the kind of place to be in a silk evening gown or a white dinner jacket...I guess it would have been difficult to justify the cable reel in the Ballroom...

reply

We should run some tests to see if it is possible...

reply

lol, probably the director found it boring to show a dozen people being sliced the same way (and rightfully so).

lol at your second question! why not? if the cable is strong enough, the force is big enough and the cable moves fast enough, why should there be a limit to how many people it can cut?
why do you care at all? it's a cheap horror-flick, forget about realism!

reply

[deleted]

The girl was dancing with the captain.



Her head came up to everyone elses shoulder



The wire cut everyone at the waist, it would of cut the girl in the stomach but somehow it went over her.

I'm watching that scene right now.

Do I CAUSE YOUR DEATH? Just like you caused Erin's?
Maserati777

reply

EVERYONE HERE'S THE ANSWER.

Pay close attention to the parts immeadiately before the passengers are severed,and you'll notice that when the cable snapped, the captain looked in the direction of the cable.

The Captain immediately realized that something was wrong AND HE CROUCHED DOWN thereby PULLING KATIE DOWN WITH HIM.

After all of the bodies fall, the camera shows a shot of Katie and the Captain alone on the dance floor surrounded by bodies. In that shot, you can sorta see that the two of them are ducking down, and in the shot immeadiately after that one, you see Katie straighten up and back away a little.

The Captain saved Katie. He pulled her down just in time for the cable to pass above her, but unfortunately, since he was taller than her, he could not save himself.

A Self-sacrifice, How Bold!

reply

[deleted]

^^^This.

reply

Because realism -> story and movie more believable -> can relate better to the movie -> higher level of enjoyment. You don't enjoy a movie much if you spend most of the time getting annoyed over all details right?

reply

The Discovery Channel show Myth Busters did an episode with a similar situation and they found that it was not likely that a cable would cut any one in half. Still seems possible though under the right conditions.

reply

I don't think it's possible but, I do think that Ghost Boobs exist. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0288477/board/thread/32187036

My only goal is to procreate satan-Gaahl

reply

Note that the ships top had different elevations, that's why some people got their head cut while others where cut at the waist.

reply

I think if the cable was going fast enough, yeah, it could cut that many people, but as for it cutting all those people in different sections, that was a VERY big mistake they had.

I am addicted and obsessed with the most random things!!!

reply

it is certainly possible for a high speed whipping cable to cut through multiple people, anyone who says differently is a ****ing idiot

reply

UH OH. Time to bring some intelligence to the debate.

Yes it's possible for a cable to kill (and sever) multiple people, if the necessary factors are ideal. The same way a launched knife could theoretically kill dozens of people.

The scene in the film would have played out differently though, all the people would not have had their bodies cleanly sliced apart, they would have just been knocked over and dragged across the deck. What's more, the power needed to sever a person, and the power needed to sever someone and their champ glass and leave both in place as if nothing had passed through them...are two very different points on a scale.

The captain did not duck down, you can see this if you actually watch the scene (why are people making points in a debate when they apparently have no useful memory of the scene is a recurring question on IMDB).

People behind the captain were cut at the torso. Perhaps the most immediate explanation would be that the cable bounced higher just before reaching the captain, conveniently missing the girl, then dropped again immediatly after. There are people in very close proximity to the captain who are apparently shorter than him, and would have survived had the cable passed them at the same height it did with the captain.

Glad to end the debate.

reply

"
Yes it's possible for a cable to kill (and sever) multiple people, if the necessary factors are ideal. The same way a launched knife could theoretically kill dozens of people. "



it's nothing like a "launched knife" (which is an incredibly idiotic comparison), whipping cables are a constant danger at sites where there is a taught metal cable holding something

for example, during construction of ski lifts, or transport systems...but probably the best examples involve transportation of lumber

reply

No, it's a perfect comparison. I could of said the same but used 'fly' instead of 'knife' and the point would remain the same. I imagine the reason my post went over your head is directly related to a fundamental lack of understanding of physics.

Also your second two points are utterly irrelevent (as they are entirely common sense) and serve no purpose except to show your naivety of the subject if you believe such information to have value enough to be worth posting.

I suppose the only question remaining is if you have the excuse of being <16 or not.

reply

Anhish is correct. The scene was ridiculous. Although cable can kill people, it would not leave them standing for seconds as if nothing had happened. The force would have knocked everyone and everything over. Even if it sliced into them, it would have knocked their bodies over immediately. I couldn't get past this scene and shut the movie off.

MOVIES BY THE MINUTE --> http://moviesbytheminute.blogspot.com

reply

Hey, come on now, your right of course, but it's no reason not to watch the movie. Having the bodies slice in half and left standing there looked way cooler than if they made it more realistic.

reply

reminds me of that scene in the first resident evil (?) the guy who got slice in to cunes by that laser

reply

Mister_Anderson said:

"I couldn't get past this scene and shut the movie off."

Lol, you must be a real douche in order to shut off a movie less than 5 minutes in because you thought one scene in a HORROR MOVIE was unrealistic. Either that or a real big liar who either never watched it of just didn't like the ending. I figure the latter.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

What matters is how taut the cable is. The tighter it's being held in place, the more force it will have when released.. it's simple physics and despite the fact that it would never happen, ever.. it's possible, but it would have to be on mythbusters or something where they create the situation on purpose because you would need advanced equipment to hold a cable in place that strong and wherever that is happening there won't be anywhere near as many people around as on the ship because it's probably going to be at a construction site. I really don't see any place other than a construction site needing the equipment that would hold a cable that tight and even then the cable would probably be vertical so if it snapped it would probably just hit the ground.

reply

That was a pretty serious cable, it looked like flexible rebar and if I'm not mistaken, it seemed like the boat's anchor cable. A few people here have already pointed out that the captain ducked down to protect Katie, who was the shortest one on that dance floor... and even if you believe it couldn't happen that way, you have to keep in mind that there was a supernatural force on that ship. As for all the baddies killing everybody else, well that was a Lot of gold for incentive and Jack was there to collect as many of their evil souls that he could get....

And I really think they were going for the shock value in those crazy scenes as well.



wooOOooo

reply

my mom's friend was decapitated in a snowmobile accident when he hit barb wire going wide open. i guess if the speed's there it could work. even if not, that was a great bit of cgi and gore in the flick.

reply

[deleted]

Damn.. they must have stolen that idea on Wrong Turn 4!

Love is Pain.

reply