MovieChat Forums > Zelary (2003) Discussion > Has anyone read the book?

Has anyone read the book?


Is there anyone who has read the novel and can comment on how close the book is to the film?

reply

The movie has some deviations from the book. In the book Richard is married, and is able to emigrate because his wife is Austrian. At the end, Hana/Eliska comes to see him as a polished self-serving skirt-chaser, and decides not to marry him.

Hana and Joza know they will have to marry from the beginning of their journey to Zelary. She reluctantly (and unnecessarily) proposes to him on the train, and then even more reluctantly seduces him on their wedding night. There are no outward temper tantrums on her part. He saved her life, and she will "not deny him his soldier's pay." For the voyeurs in you, the seduction scene in the movie is reasonably faithful to the book.

Many of the suspense scenes, on the other hand, were invented strictly for the film. The book has no lynching Germans, no rapists, no baby stalkers. The only serious fighting occurs at the end, and is handled in one brief chapter. And Joza, thankfully, dies in the arms of his wife.

The focus of the book is on the characters, their love, their friendships, and their way of life. I found the book descriptive, touching, and poetic. It isn't available in English yet, although I find it never hurts to lean on major booksellers.

reply

Thank you very much!

reply

Thank you. So, she doesn't end up with Richard at the end? What happens to her after WWII?

reply

The book was vague about Richard at the end. Hana went back to work and grieved deeply for Joza, with Richard telling her he understood, thinking it must have been traumatic. Hana didn't explain. That's how the book ended. I think Kveta Legatova wanted us to decide the rest for ourselves.

Since Richard's marital status was left blank in the movie, it's possible the director was hinting that they did end up together. But in the book Richard was married, and she had come to see him as a common skirt-chaser. So even if she later took some comfort with him, it would have been temporary.

I like to think that they were just friends and collegues, and that she wanted him to see how she lived during the war.


reply

Thanks for the info.

reply